What do you think?
Rate this book
The Celestial Isles #1
The Electrical Menagerie
For fans of Caraval and The Greatest Showman: a quest for fame and fortune in a stardust-powered empire brings debt, scandal, and danger in spades.
The Electrical Menagerie, one-of-a-kind robotic roadshow, is bankrupt.
Sylvester Carthage, illusionist and engineer, has the eccentric imagination the Menagerie needs to succeed creatively — but none of the people skills. Fast-talking Arbrook Huxley, meanwhile, has all the savvy the Menagerie needs to succeed commercially — but none of the scruples.
To save their show, Carthage & Huxley stake everything in a royal talent competition, vying for the once-in-a-lifetime chance to perform for the Future Celestial Queen. In this stardust-and-spark-powered empire of floating islands and flying trains, the Menagerie's bid at fame and fortune means weathering the glamorous and cutthroat world of critics, high society, and rival magicians — but with real conspiracy lurking beneath tabloid controversy, there's more at stake in this contest than the prize.
Behind the glittery haze of flash paper and mirrors, every competitor has something to hide… and it’s the lies Carthage & Huxley tell each other that may cost them everything.
______________________________________
"Dazzles from start to finish. In Carthage & Huxley, Sherlock & Watson fans will find another dynamic duo whose ready wit and sizzling banter (and inevitable personality clashes) never fail to delight. You'll be calling for an encore performance." Gillian Bronte Adams, author of The Songkeeper Chronicles
"The stuff that fandoms are built on." Kyle Robert Shultz, author of Beaumont & Beasley
______________________________________
The Celestial Isles is a new series for fans of steampunk, science fiction, and fairy tales.
The Electrical Menagerie, one-of-a-kind robotic roadshow, is bankrupt.
Sylvester Carthage, illusionist and engineer, has the eccentric imagination the Menagerie needs to succeed creatively — but none of the people skills. Fast-talking Arbrook Huxley, meanwhile, has all the savvy the Menagerie needs to succeed commercially — but none of the scruples.
To save their show, Carthage & Huxley stake everything in a royal talent competition, vying for the once-in-a-lifetime chance to perform for the Future Celestial Queen. In this stardust-and-spark-powered empire of floating islands and flying trains, the Menagerie's bid at fame and fortune means weathering the glamorous and cutthroat world of critics, high society, and rival magicians — but with real conspiracy lurking beneath tabloid controversy, there's more at stake in this contest than the prize.
Behind the glittery haze of flash paper and mirrors, every competitor has something to hide… and it’s the lies Carthage & Huxley tell each other that may cost them everything.
______________________________________
"Dazzles from start to finish. In Carthage & Huxley, Sherlock & Watson fans will find another dynamic duo whose ready wit and sizzling banter (and inevitable personality clashes) never fail to delight. You'll be calling for an encore performance." Gillian Bronte Adams, author of The Songkeeper Chronicles
"The stuff that fandoms are built on." Kyle Robert Shultz, author of Beaumont & Beasley
______________________________________
The Celestial Isles is a new series for fans of steampunk, science fiction, and fairy tales.
325 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2018
About the author
Mollie E. Reeder
5 books68 followersMollie’s first job was with a major theme park, where she operated a roller coaster, fixed parade floats, and helped Scooby-Doo put on his head. Now, Mollie is a movie producer and the author of character-driven science fiction/fantasy novels for adults who never outgrew imagination. Her favorite things include Jesus, dinosaurs, and telling cinematic stories that blend glitter and grit.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 127 reviews
August 22, 2019
A brilliant, electric, engaging, deep, heartwarming, powerful, and character-driven novel. I immensely enjoyed nearly every moment and detail of The Electrical Menagerie by Mollie E. Reeder. It’s bright and warm and joyful, yet sometimes gritty and raw and dark, and it’s an entertaining adventure that has surprising depth of theme and heart. The Electrical Menagerie is primarily fascinating steampunk--with a dash of sci-fi, a healthy dose of real-feeling fantasy, and a rich background that reminds me of Sherlock Holmes-style Victorian Britain, while also being totally its own. I wouldn’t have thought I would enjoy steampunk, and this is the first time I’ve ever read steampunk fiction--but I absolutely loved the book, including the steampunk element.
I loved so many aspects of this stellar and exemplary book. The characters and relationships are vivid and real, the setting and worldbuilding is imaginative and totally unique, the writing style is potent and powerful, the themes are poignantly gorgeous and meaningful, and the plot is riveting, twisty, well-paced, and skillfully woven. The story and each of its words are expertly crafted, packing an electrifying punch. I enjoyed the fact that it’s an adventure story, and that it’s focused on a male friendship--an awesome duo of men, at that. But it also has strong female characters in a prominent role, which I appreciate.
The Electrical Menagerie immediately made it into the ranks of my all-time favorite books, and my top five favorites of this year. It kept me up much too late at night, and I tore through it at record speed--a fraction of the time it usually takes me to read a book of this length.
The characters of The Electrical Menagerie, especially the protagonist, Carthage, were by far my favorite part of the book. I loved the characters’ personalities and character arcs--again, Carthage in particular. Several of the characters were lifelike and well-developed, so that they leaped off the page in energetic and fascinating detail. Huxley was my other favorite--I found his high-strung, intense personality, boyish wildness, and hidden struggles endearing. Most of the other characters weren't as compelling as the two main guys, but that duo made the entire book.
But my favorite aspect of the book was, without a doubt, the protagonist. I deeply, deeply identified with Carthage, because of what he goes through and because of his past. That isn’t usually true for a character that much older than me. And I loved him as a person, even without that. He has a sweet, innocent, childlike spirit, wonder, and imagination. But he’s also a strong, mature man with unwavering and noble character and ideals. He succeeds in embodying the best aspects of childhood and manhood. He has a soaring ability to dream sparkling dreams, chase them, and succeed in capturing them, while also being honest, humble, and down-to-earth. And I love that he’s compassionate and kind--that’s one of the most important things. But underneath, he’s insecure, hurting, and struggling--while all the while keeping it locked away deep inside, behind a confident exterior. My heart went out to him from the first page, and I spent the whole book wanting to protect and comfort him and keep him safe--while also knowing that with his strong, independent, manly personality, he’d hate that! I loved Carthage’s characterization and character development so much, and I loved watching him grow. He felt so, so real to me, like someone I know intimately--like a beloved friend, but in an even deeper way than that, because his skillfully written narration conveyed all his thoughts and feelings in a sharply powerful yet understated way.
I identified with Carthage so deeply that this book made me cry, not once, but twice within a single chapter, only the second chapter of the book. And throughout the first chapter, I was overwhelmed by wave after wave of emotion as I experienced the brilliantly written, sweetly heartbreaking scene and discovered the story and main character for the first time. My heart broke for him from the first, and I longed for him to find healing and peace. What he’s been through reminds me of what I have been through. And the second time I cried, I sobbed for myself as well as him. It’s rare that I cry actual tears in a book--it has to move me very deeply and take me completely by surprise, so I don’t usually cry real tears even though I emote. But this book made me freely and uncontrollably weep/bawl/sob with tears streaming down my face. The good kind of tears--the healing, freeing kind. Because not only did Carthage’s pain remind me of my own--his story and narration also conveyed a vital, healing truth I desperately needed to hear at the time I read the book, in a way that couldn’t have broke through to me if I had heard it from another source than this vivid, powerfully written novel. Carthage’s themes and character development, his struggles and his journey, were deep and poignant, and I loved every part of him and his story.
On a lighter note, this book made me laugh quite often, as well as making me cry! I chuckled or grinned at the wit and humor, at the entertaining interactions, mishaps, characters, and banter. Huxley was particularly hilarious from his first page, but so was Carthage, and their relationship was best of all.
The writing style was sharp and skillful, with an incredible and explosive impact. Each sentence was powerful and meaningful. I loved it so much. The author chose her words so perfectly, and her style is clear, crisp, and concise, never wasting a word. That said, almost my only complaint about this book--an miniscule one, for the sake of objectivity--was that in spite of the overall clarity, the occasional sentence lacked clarity because of the author’s concise style. I’m all for making every word count, and omitting any that are unnecessary, and the author does it incredibly well. But I think clarity is very important, and it’s important not to lose it. Again, that was an incredibly minor complaint that did not detract from my enjoyment in the least--and only a few sentences in the entire book had that problem. I applaud Ms. Reeder’s stellar writing, and the whole time I was reading, I was noticing wonderful sentences and basking in the joy of reading such a powerfully and skillfully written book.
Practically the only other thing that I found lacking was that the climax wasn’t nearly as spectacular or exciting as the rest of the book. The entire book was spent reeling from perfectly timed punches and recovery, with more and more amazing events. And there were some pretty exciting things that happened in the climax, but it didn’t quite match the build-up of the rest. However, I was so captivated that I barely noticed that, and it didn’t keep me from enjoying the climax and everything else--cause the characters are what I care about the most.
Practically the only other thing that I found lacking was that the climax wasn’t nearly as spectacular or exciting as the rest of the book. The entire book was spent reeling from perfectly timed punches and recovery, with more and more amazing events. And there were some pretty exciting things that happened in the climax, but it didn’t quite match the build-up of the rest. However, I was so captivated that I barely noticed that, and it didn’t keep me from enjoying the climax and everything else--cause the characters are what I care about the most.
I’m so, so glad I read this book. I almost didn’t. When I first heard about The Electrical Menagerie, I thought it looked like a great book, but not one I’d enjoy. I refused to read it even when a dear friend raved about it and told me I might love it. But she pestered me so much--and I trust her so much--that I finally heeded her and agreed to read it. I still wasn’t sure if I’d like it, but I thought there was a chance I would. But everything I kept hearing after that made me more and more excited to read The Electrical Menagerie, until I was nearly certain I’d love it--so much that it was at the top of my list of books to read and buy. I’m so glad I read it, and that I invested in a gorgeous paperback. Just look at that stellar blue-and-gold cover of the edition I own, and the elephant!!
I had very high expectations, but this book blew all of them away, and was completely unexpected and wonderful. My friend was right--I did love it. Far more, and in deeper and more personal ways, than I ever could have guessed! I’m so, so grateful to her for urging me to read it, because it’s a new favorite. I’ve already passed on the favor by recommending it ardently to other friends. My younger brother read and adored it already, and even my little sister--to young to read it yet--was exhilarated by the cover and the first hint of a premise, and she’s already dying to read it when she’s old enough.
I’m so glad I knew nearly nothing about this book when I started reading it--that allowed me to discover the story for myself as the author and characters skillfully revealed it to me, as I watched in wide-eyed, joyous wonder. I knew that it was something about a steampunk circus, but I didn’t know anything else--and I loved everything about it. So I won’t spoil any other details for anyone else, besides vague discussion of the characters.
This was my first time reading anything remotely steampunk, and I thought I wouldn’t like that aspect--but I adored even that, and it fascinated and delighted me. This book was a fantastic introduction to the genre, and it had just the right amount of steampunk without overwhelming me with robots I care nothing about--though it had . I’m not too big on most speculative fiction, except some types of fantasy, but this fantastical, out-of-this-world book won me over completely from the first.
The Electrical Menagerie is classified as adult fiction, and most of the characters are adults, but it’s the sort of book that can be enjoyed equally by teens and adults of all ages. I recommend it for teens and up because of moderate violence () and mild romance (). It’s nothing that would bother most teens, though extremely sensitive readers of any age would have a problem with the violence.
Let me pause here to say that this is exactly the type of book I’ve been craving--wholesome fiction for adults that appeals to all ages--and that doesn’t have any of the grossness or darkness that’s present in so much of adult and young adult fiction. In addition, it’s timeless and adventurous, both of which are things I love in any book. The Electrical Menagerie has such a bright, youthful quality, but the protagonist can’t be called young--and he himself has a youthfulness and a great maturity. I’ve been wanting fiction just like this, and I’ve been satisfied for now--but I want more!
I’ve heard people compare The Electrical Menagerie to The Greatest Showman and Jules Verne, and I heartily agree that it would appeal to fans of both. But I haven’t seen The Greatest Showman, and I haven’t read Jules Verne except for Around the World in Eighty Days--and I don’t think I’d enjoy either one. But I LOVED The Electrical Menagerie, so I recommend it highly whether or not you enjoy either of those other works.
The Electrical Menagerie would appeal to anyone who loves sci-fi, or fantasy, or historical fantasy--even though it’s none of those, it has elements of all three. And if you like historical fiction and don’t mind a dose of fantasy thrown in, or if you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes, you’ll love this as well. If you love steampunk or Jules Verne, however, this is absolutely a must-read! I don’t like steampunk, but I loved even the steampunk aspects of this book, so don’t be shy about reading it if you’re like me. So whoever you are, and whatever your tastes--go read The Electrical Menagerie without delay!
I absolutely cannot wait to read more by Ms. Reeder, and I’m eagerly anticipating the Celestial Isles sequels.
A glowing 5 stars. Highly, highly recommended.
I loved so many aspects of this stellar and exemplary book. The characters and relationships are vivid and real, the setting and worldbuilding is imaginative and totally unique, the writing style is potent and powerful, the themes are poignantly gorgeous and meaningful, and the plot is riveting, twisty, well-paced, and skillfully woven. The story and each of its words are expertly crafted, packing an electrifying punch. I enjoyed the fact that it’s an adventure story, and that it’s focused on a male friendship--an awesome duo of men, at that. But it also has strong female characters in a prominent role, which I appreciate.
The Electrical Menagerie immediately made it into the ranks of my all-time favorite books, and my top five favorites of this year. It kept me up much too late at night, and I tore through it at record speed--a fraction of the time it usually takes me to read a book of this length.
The characters of The Electrical Menagerie, especially the protagonist, Carthage, were by far my favorite part of the book. I loved the characters’ personalities and character arcs--again, Carthage in particular. Several of the characters were lifelike and well-developed, so that they leaped off the page in energetic and fascinating detail. Huxley was my other favorite--I found his high-strung, intense personality, boyish wildness, and hidden struggles endearing. Most of the other characters weren't as compelling as the two main guys, but that duo made the entire book.
But my favorite aspect of the book was, without a doubt, the protagonist. I deeply, deeply identified with Carthage, because of what he goes through and because of his past. That isn’t usually true for a character that much older than me. And I loved him as a person, even without that. He has a sweet, innocent, childlike spirit, wonder, and imagination. But he’s also a strong, mature man with unwavering and noble character and ideals. He succeeds in embodying the best aspects of childhood and manhood. He has a soaring ability to dream sparkling dreams, chase them, and succeed in capturing them, while also being honest, humble, and down-to-earth. And I love that he’s compassionate and kind--that’s one of the most important things. But underneath, he’s insecure, hurting, and struggling--while all the while keeping it locked away deep inside, behind a confident exterior. My heart went out to him from the first page, and I spent the whole book wanting to protect and comfort him and keep him safe--while also knowing that with his strong, independent, manly personality, he’d hate that! I loved Carthage’s characterization and character development so much, and I loved watching him grow. He felt so, so real to me, like someone I know intimately--like a beloved friend, but in an even deeper way than that, because his skillfully written narration conveyed all his thoughts and feelings in a sharply powerful yet understated way.
I identified with Carthage so deeply that this book made me cry, not once, but twice within a single chapter, only the second chapter of the book. And throughout the first chapter, I was overwhelmed by wave after wave of emotion as I experienced the brilliantly written, sweetly heartbreaking scene and discovered the story and main character for the first time. My heart broke for him from the first, and I longed for him to find healing and peace. What he’s been through reminds me of what I have been through. And the second time I cried, I sobbed for myself as well as him. It’s rare that I cry actual tears in a book--it has to move me very deeply and take me completely by surprise, so I don’t usually cry real tears even though I emote. But this book made me freely and uncontrollably weep/bawl/sob with tears streaming down my face. The good kind of tears--the healing, freeing kind. Because not only did Carthage’s pain remind me of my own--his story and narration also conveyed a vital, healing truth I desperately needed to hear at the time I read the book, in a way that couldn’t have broke through to me if I had heard it from another source than this vivid, powerfully written novel. Carthage’s themes and character development, his struggles and his journey, were deep and poignant, and I loved every part of him and his story.
On a lighter note, this book made me laugh quite often, as well as making me cry! I chuckled or grinned at the wit and humor, at the entertaining interactions, mishaps, characters, and banter. Huxley was particularly hilarious from his first page, but so was Carthage, and their relationship was best of all.
The writing style was sharp and skillful, with an incredible and explosive impact. Each sentence was powerful and meaningful. I loved it so much. The author chose her words so perfectly, and her style is clear, crisp, and concise, never wasting a word. That said, almost my only complaint about this book--an miniscule one, for the sake of objectivity--was that in spite of the overall clarity, the occasional sentence lacked clarity because of the author’s concise style. I’m all for making every word count, and omitting any that are unnecessary, and the author does it incredibly well. But I think clarity is very important, and it’s important not to lose it. Again, that was an incredibly minor complaint that did not detract from my enjoyment in the least--and only a few sentences in the entire book had that problem. I applaud Ms. Reeder’s stellar writing, and the whole time I was reading, I was noticing wonderful sentences and basking in the joy of reading such a powerfully and skillfully written book.
Practically the only other thing that I found lacking was that the climax wasn’t nearly as spectacular or exciting as the rest of the book. The entire book was spent reeling from perfectly timed punches and recovery, with more and more amazing events. And there were some pretty exciting things that happened in the climax, but it didn’t quite match the build-up of the rest. However, I was so captivated that I barely noticed that, and it didn’t keep me from enjoying the climax and everything else--cause the characters are what I care about the most.
Practically the only other thing that I found lacking was that the climax wasn’t nearly as spectacular or exciting as the rest of the book. The entire book was spent reeling from perfectly timed punches and recovery, with more and more amazing events. And there were some pretty exciting things that happened in the climax, but it didn’t quite match the build-up of the rest. However, I was so captivated that I barely noticed that, and it didn’t keep me from enjoying the climax and everything else--cause the characters are what I care about the most.
I’m so, so glad I read this book. I almost didn’t. When I first heard about The Electrical Menagerie, I thought it looked like a great book, but not one I’d enjoy. I refused to read it even when a dear friend raved about it and told me I might love it. But she pestered me so much--and I trust her so much--that I finally heeded her and agreed to read it. I still wasn’t sure if I’d like it, but I thought there was a chance I would. But everything I kept hearing after that made me more and more excited to read The Electrical Menagerie, until I was nearly certain I’d love it--so much that it was at the top of my list of books to read and buy. I’m so glad I read it, and that I invested in a gorgeous paperback. Just look at that stellar blue-and-gold cover of the edition I own, and the elephant!!
I had very high expectations, but this book blew all of them away, and was completely unexpected and wonderful. My friend was right--I did love it. Far more, and in deeper and more personal ways, than I ever could have guessed! I’m so, so grateful to her for urging me to read it, because it’s a new favorite. I’ve already passed on the favor by recommending it ardently to other friends. My younger brother read and adored it already, and even my little sister--to young to read it yet--was exhilarated by the cover and the first hint of a premise, and she’s already dying to read it when she’s old enough.
I’m so glad I knew nearly nothing about this book when I started reading it--that allowed me to discover the story for myself as the author and characters skillfully revealed it to me, as I watched in wide-eyed, joyous wonder. I knew that it was something about a steampunk circus, but I didn’t know anything else--and I loved everything about it. So I won’t spoil any other details for anyone else, besides vague discussion of the characters.
This was my first time reading anything remotely steampunk, and I thought I wouldn’t like that aspect--but I adored even that, and it fascinated and delighted me. This book was a fantastic introduction to the genre, and it had just the right amount of steampunk without overwhelming me with robots I care nothing about--though it had . I’m not too big on most speculative fiction, except some types of fantasy, but this fantastical, out-of-this-world book won me over completely from the first.
The Electrical Menagerie is classified as adult fiction, and most of the characters are adults, but it’s the sort of book that can be enjoyed equally by teens and adults of all ages. I recommend it for teens and up because of moderate violence () and mild romance (). It’s nothing that would bother most teens, though extremely sensitive readers of any age would have a problem with the violence.
Let me pause here to say that this is exactly the type of book I’ve been craving--wholesome fiction for adults that appeals to all ages--and that doesn’t have any of the grossness or darkness that’s present in so much of adult and young adult fiction. In addition, it’s timeless and adventurous, both of which are things I love in any book. The Electrical Menagerie has such a bright, youthful quality, but the protagonist can’t be called young--and he himself has a youthfulness and a great maturity. I’ve been wanting fiction just like this, and I’ve been satisfied for now--but I want more!
I’ve heard people compare The Electrical Menagerie to The Greatest Showman and Jules Verne, and I heartily agree that it would appeal to fans of both. But I haven’t seen The Greatest Showman, and I haven’t read Jules Verne except for Around the World in Eighty Days--and I don’t think I’d enjoy either one. But I LOVED The Electrical Menagerie, so I recommend it highly whether or not you enjoy either of those other works.
The Electrical Menagerie would appeal to anyone who loves sci-fi, or fantasy, or historical fantasy--even though it’s none of those, it has elements of all three. And if you like historical fiction and don’t mind a dose of fantasy thrown in, or if you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes, you’ll love this as well. If you love steampunk or Jules Verne, however, this is absolutely a must-read! I don’t like steampunk, but I loved even the steampunk aspects of this book, so don’t be shy about reading it if you’re like me. So whoever you are, and whatever your tastes--go read The Electrical Menagerie without delay!
I absolutely cannot wait to read more by Ms. Reeder, and I’m eagerly anticipating the Celestial Isles sequels.
A glowing 5 stars. Highly, highly recommended.
August 22, 2018
An almost entirely SPOILER-FREE REVIEW.
Without a doubt, this one of the best books I’ve read in 2018.
I had seen a lot of excitement around The Electrical Menagerie’s release and I am always constrained when reading a hyped book but this book did more than not disappoint—it carried all my expectations like the crest of a wave as I was immersed in this beautiful story and world. I stayed up far into the wee hours to finish TEM simply because it was impossible to put it down.
THE CHARACTERS.
It’s been a while since I’ve read such well-crafted characters. Every piece of dialogue, every scene—it is all constructed with skill and care. Reeder has true control over her characters and story, and wields her power masterfully.
CARTHAGE. I was overjoyed to find that Sylvester was an older character—age-wise—and I was touched by his childlike personality and his incredibly sad back story. Carthage is the heart of The Electrical Menagerie—a flawed, flinching, damaged heart hiding beneath a cloak of glitter and illusion. It would have been easy for an author to let showy characters like Huxley or quirky ones like Dominic to steal the show, but Carthage remains firmly at the center in all his subtle, gentle beauty—and I gasped and had tears in my eyes as his moving character arc was laid bare.
I could also relate to Sylvester’s physical limitations and pain, and I really appreciated Ms. Reeder’s inclusion of a character that is heroic because of the tenacity they display in their physical weakness. We need more of this in fiction and I really appreciated seeing that in TEM.
HUXLEY. What a treat. A delightful smooth-talking, smooth-walking, smooth-operating genteel salesman. But far from being a one-dimensional charmer, Huxley was fully developed with a heavy dose of thoughtfulness, quirkiness and practicality and had his own poignant arc developing nicely. It was also delightful to find a romance burgeoning for the “sidekick” instead of our main character.
DOMINIC. Oh my heart! That dear, darling little robot! I want to hug his dear head. I am a perfect sap for robot characters, and I was delighted that this character remains a robot. Instead of grasping at humanity, Dominic remains unquestionably a machine. It coincides with my favorite treatment of robots of all time - George Lucas's stipulation that: robots ought to possess a personality, but no soul. And yet there is an incredibly amount of soulfulness in Dominic in his role of observer to the humans around him. I simply cannot express my how enamored I am with this precious little electrical. I squealed, I moaned. I CRIED.
Last of all, this story is built around a buddy story. Oh my goodness people, I will jump through hoops to see a good male buddy story and this book provided an utterly satisfying take on that classic relationship.
THE WORLDBUILDING
Did I mention there are robots? Robots of all kinds?
I’m finding difficulty locating the appropriate superlatives to describe the thrill of Reeder’s world building. The Celestial Isles, the electricals, the circus, the cities. It’s bogglingly interesting and my little steampunk heart was thrilled right down to the ground with how Reeder took steampunk and put an entirely new twist on its settings.
And I mentioned the robots, right?
The Menagerie is one of the main backdrops in this captivating world, and there were several show-stopping moments featuring the Menagerie and I kept wondering each time how Reeder would top the previous act, but each magical performance was airy, joyous and full of wonder.
And did I mention there are robots?
One especial world building highlight for me was the isle that was based on the Deep South—I wouldn’t have thought of using the South as a cultural basis for one of the Isles and I thought that was really clever.
THE STORY
Rollicking, thoughtful, heartfelt, thrilling, introspective, gentle and breezy – it’s all here, fine details etched against a background of spectacle. The plot kept developing in ways I didn’t expect and held my attention for every page. There was one point involving Dominic that had me shrieking and moaning that I can’t relate here because of spoilers.
STYLE
Clear and smooth and (unlike many female authors who can be over-emotional) written with subtlety and restraint. She writes male characters and their banter with refreshing straightforwardness and her background in show business also stamps the book with a tough realism as technical detail sprinkle the pages.
QUIBBLES
The only character I didn’t care for was Andromeda. She honestly felt like a character I’ve seen a lot and was a tad annoying.
The finale felt a little rushed. After such an incredible build-up, I expected a bit more spectacle for the final action sequence and a bit more development for the surprise character at the end.
SUMMARIZATION
So many authors (specifically Christian ones) are hampered by forcing morals into their stories when the stories themselves are not as strong as they could be—like focusing on the paint when there is structural damage. Consequently, the moral itself falls flat.
But Reeder rises above that pitfall. Her faith seeps through the story’s exceptional craftsmanship. There is nothing sloppy here; it bears the mark of a dedicated artisan. The plot and the arcs resonate with truth without Reeder having to over enunciate the lessons or her faith. Nothing is bludgeoned, nothing is marred.
I was nourished by The Electrical Menagerie. I have read an abundance of books this year, but the stellar have been few and far between, and that search for the exceptional was satisfied in TEM.
First and foremost, it is a good wheel – as attractive as a warm fire, as flavorful as a nourishing soup – and I enjoyed every single bite.
Reeder has touched upon the key that every author should know – that an author’s primary goal is to entertain . . . and Reeder does more than entertain—she enchants.
Without a doubt, this one of the best books I’ve read in 2018.
I had seen a lot of excitement around The Electrical Menagerie’s release and I am always constrained when reading a hyped book but this book did more than not disappoint—it carried all my expectations like the crest of a wave as I was immersed in this beautiful story and world. I stayed up far into the wee hours to finish TEM simply because it was impossible to put it down.
THE CHARACTERS.
It’s been a while since I’ve read such well-crafted characters. Every piece of dialogue, every scene—it is all constructed with skill and care. Reeder has true control over her characters and story, and wields her power masterfully.
CARTHAGE. I was overjoyed to find that Sylvester was an older character—age-wise—and I was touched by his childlike personality and his incredibly sad back story. Carthage is the heart of The Electrical Menagerie—a flawed, flinching, damaged heart hiding beneath a cloak of glitter and illusion. It would have been easy for an author to let showy characters like Huxley or quirky ones like Dominic to steal the show, but Carthage remains firmly at the center in all his subtle, gentle beauty—and I gasped and had tears in my eyes as his moving character arc was laid bare.
I could also relate to Sylvester’s physical limitations and pain, and I really appreciated Ms. Reeder’s inclusion of a character that is heroic because of the tenacity they display in their physical weakness. We need more of this in fiction and I really appreciated seeing that in TEM.
HUXLEY. What a treat. A delightful smooth-talking, smooth-walking, smooth-operating genteel salesman. But far from being a one-dimensional charmer, Huxley was fully developed with a heavy dose of thoughtfulness, quirkiness and practicality and had his own poignant arc developing nicely. It was also delightful to find a romance burgeoning for the “sidekick” instead of our main character.
DOMINIC. Oh my heart! That dear, darling little robot! I want to hug his dear head. I am a perfect sap for robot characters, and I was delighted that this character remains a robot. Instead of grasping at humanity, Dominic remains unquestionably a machine. It coincides with my favorite treatment of robots of all time - George Lucas's stipulation that: robots ought to possess a personality, but no soul. And yet there is an incredibly amount of soulfulness in Dominic in his role of observer to the humans around him. I simply cannot express my how enamored I am with this precious little electrical. I squealed, I moaned. I CRIED.
Last of all, this story is built around a buddy story. Oh my goodness people, I will jump through hoops to see a good male buddy story and this book provided an utterly satisfying take on that classic relationship.
THE WORLDBUILDING
Did I mention there are robots? Robots of all kinds?
I’m finding difficulty locating the appropriate superlatives to describe the thrill of Reeder’s world building. The Celestial Isles, the electricals, the circus, the cities. It’s bogglingly interesting and my little steampunk heart was thrilled right down to the ground with how Reeder took steampunk and put an entirely new twist on its settings.
And I mentioned the robots, right?
The Menagerie is one of the main backdrops in this captivating world, and there were several show-stopping moments featuring the Menagerie and I kept wondering each time how Reeder would top the previous act, but each magical performance was airy, joyous and full of wonder.
And did I mention there are robots?
One especial world building highlight for me was the isle that was based on the Deep South—I wouldn’t have thought of using the South as a cultural basis for one of the Isles and I thought that was really clever.
THE STORY
Rollicking, thoughtful, heartfelt, thrilling, introspective, gentle and breezy – it’s all here, fine details etched against a background of spectacle. The plot kept developing in ways I didn’t expect and held my attention for every page. There was one point involving Dominic that had me shrieking and moaning that I can’t relate here because of spoilers.
STYLE
Clear and smooth and (unlike many female authors who can be over-emotional) written with subtlety and restraint. She writes male characters and their banter with refreshing straightforwardness and her background in show business also stamps the book with a tough realism as technical detail sprinkle the pages.
QUIBBLES
The only character I didn’t care for was Andromeda. She honestly felt like a character I’ve seen a lot and was a tad annoying.
The finale felt a little rushed. After such an incredible build-up, I expected a bit more spectacle for the final action sequence and a bit more development for the surprise character at the end.
SUMMARIZATION
So many authors (specifically Christian ones) are hampered by forcing morals into their stories when the stories themselves are not as strong as they could be—like focusing on the paint when there is structural damage. Consequently, the moral itself falls flat.
But Reeder rises above that pitfall. Her faith seeps through the story’s exceptional craftsmanship. There is nothing sloppy here; it bears the mark of a dedicated artisan. The plot and the arcs resonate with truth without Reeder having to over enunciate the lessons or her faith. Nothing is bludgeoned, nothing is marred.
“The world does not need more Christian literature. What it needs is more Christians writing good literature.” C.S. Lewis
“We needn’t all write patently moral or theological work. Indeed, work whose Christianity is latent may do quite as much good and may reach some whom the more obvious religious work would scare away. The first business of a story is to be a good story. When Our Lord made a wheel in the carpenter shop, depend upon it: It was first and foremost a good wheel. A good story which will give innocent pleasure is a good thing, just like cooking a good nourishing meal.” C.S. Lewis
I was nourished by The Electrical Menagerie. I have read an abundance of books this year, but the stellar have been few and far between, and that search for the exceptional was satisfied in TEM.
First and foremost, it is a good wheel – as attractive as a warm fire, as flavorful as a nourishing soup – and I enjoyed every single bite.
Reeder has touched upon the key that every author should know – that an author’s primary goal is to entertain . . . and Reeder does more than entertain—she enchants.
January 21, 2020
Update 2020: I have read this book three times now, and it’s still just as magical as ever. I will never get tired of Carthage and Huxley.
———————
~ I received a free advance review copy of The Electrical Menagerie, therefore all of the following opinions are my own ~
This book is absolutely magical in every way. This is the kind of book that swallows you up so thoroughly, you can’t stop thinking about it, even when you’re not reading. It’s heartfelt, imaginative, and filled with characters that I connected with from the very beginning. I knew after reading Arbrook Huxley and the Star-Crossed Lovers that I was in for a treat, but The Electrical Menagerie delivered—and then some.
Sylvester Carthage: This man is one of the most complex and well-developed characters I’ve seen in a while. There were a lot of times while reading his POV that I had to sit back and think, “Wow. That’s exactly what [that] feels like.” Even feelings I’d never consciously thought about. Reeder enabled me to connect with him from page one, and my sister will be the first to tell you that I got more than a little animated while telling her about him. He was strong in an extremely understated way—without even knowing it himself—and grew tremendously throughout the course of the book.
Arbrook Huxley: Huxley provided an effective foil for Carthage, who was a very morally upright character. Although he was a "good person" over all, Huxley was not averse to using underhand means to achieve desired ends from time to time. He’s also rather foulmouthed (in a made-up way), something that drives Carthage nuts—but over the course of the story, Huxley grew a lot, and learned to appreciate his quiet business partner. They both had something to teach the other, and I love that.
As for the world itself, I was constantly blown away by how well thought-out it was. I never had to scramble for a mental image, because Reeder always painted the picture in glowing colors. (And, unlike Tolkien, did not spend five pages lecturing on the state of the hills from all four points of the compass.) The murder-mystery side of the story had me constantly guessing, but there were enough personal battles to keep me engaged in that direction as well. I believed in Carthage and Huxley from the very beginning... even if they didn’t always believe in each other. Also, can I just say that Reeder got me attached to a robot? I mean really. The poor guy deserved better!
And now we come to the part of the review where I gripe at nitpicky things—except—I have nothing to gripe about. Maybe some of the tricks could have been explained a little better, and perhaps the first show in the book could have been elaborated on just a tad bit more, but other than that, I have nothing. All of the plot points were wrapped up in a neat little bow at the end, and nothing was left hanging. As for a content warning, there is quite a bit of drinking, and one character ends up rather drunk… but that only makes him incredibly sarcastic. Huxley’s habit of cursing doesn’t even count against the book, because every oath was made up!
In closing, I feel extremely privileged to have been able to enter the realm of The Electrical Menagerie. Thank you, Reeder, for providing me with an ARC of this marvelous book. I am looking forward to seeing more of Carthage and Huxley in the future!
———————
~ I received a free advance review copy of The Electrical Menagerie, therefore all of the following opinions are my own ~
This book is absolutely magical in every way. This is the kind of book that swallows you up so thoroughly, you can’t stop thinking about it, even when you’re not reading. It’s heartfelt, imaginative, and filled with characters that I connected with from the very beginning. I knew after reading Arbrook Huxley and the Star-Crossed Lovers that I was in for a treat, but The Electrical Menagerie delivered—and then some.
Sylvester Carthage: This man is one of the most complex and well-developed characters I’ve seen in a while. There were a lot of times while reading his POV that I had to sit back and think, “Wow. That’s exactly what [that] feels like.” Even feelings I’d never consciously thought about. Reeder enabled me to connect with him from page one, and my sister will be the first to tell you that I got more than a little animated while telling her about him. He was strong in an extremely understated way—without even knowing it himself—and grew tremendously throughout the course of the book.
Arbrook Huxley: Huxley provided an effective foil for Carthage, who was a very morally upright character. Although he was a "good person" over all, Huxley was not averse to using underhand means to achieve desired ends from time to time. He’s also rather foulmouthed (in a made-up way), something that drives Carthage nuts—but over the course of the story, Huxley grew a lot, and learned to appreciate his quiet business partner. They both had something to teach the other, and I love that.
As for the world itself, I was constantly blown away by how well thought-out it was. I never had to scramble for a mental image, because Reeder always painted the picture in glowing colors. (And, unlike Tolkien, did not spend five pages lecturing on the state of the hills from all four points of the compass.) The murder-mystery side of the story had me constantly guessing, but there were enough personal battles to keep me engaged in that direction as well. I believed in Carthage and Huxley from the very beginning... even if they didn’t always believe in each other. Also, can I just say that Reeder got me attached to a robot? I mean really. The poor guy deserved better!
And now we come to the part of the review where I gripe at nitpicky things—except—I have nothing to gripe about. Maybe some of the tricks could have been explained a little better, and perhaps the first show in the book could have been elaborated on just a tad bit more, but other than that, I have nothing. All of the plot points were wrapped up in a neat little bow at the end, and nothing was left hanging. As for a content warning, there is quite a bit of drinking, and one character ends up rather drunk… but that only makes him incredibly sarcastic. Huxley’s habit of cursing doesn’t even count against the book, because every oath was made up!
In closing, I feel extremely privileged to have been able to enter the realm of The Electrical Menagerie. Thank you, Reeder, for providing me with an ARC of this marvelous book. I am looking forward to seeing more of Carthage and Huxley in the future!
March 14, 2019
The Electrical Menagerie by Mollie E. Reeder and narrated by Travis Baldree is an audible book I requested and the review is voluntary. This was a fresh change from what I had been reading. I love steampunk and this was excellent! Adding in a circus feel, the steampunk, and then murder, and more, it took this novel over the 'big top'! Loved the characters, especially one of the "electricals". Plot and twists kept the story rolling.
With Travis Baldree as narrator is was bound to be good! Excellent voices and emotions! Great job!
With Travis Baldree as narrator is was bound to be good! Excellent voices and emotions! Great job!
September 19, 2022
(Edit: I finally saw The Greatest Showman, and if you love that movie you NEED to read The Electrical Menagerie, because The Electrical Menagerie is even better. <3)
(Also posted on my book blog: 10 Reasons You Should Read The Electrical Menagerie.)
1. What did I just read? *deep breath* I LOVED THIS BOOK. It was absolutely delightful and I have a book hangover—how will anything ever be this good again? AAHH. *collapses and wails and longs for a sequel* I don’t think I’ve ever read anything like this but it was INCREDIBLE and just so much fun! :D
2. The humor! It’s an utterly hilarious book and I LOVE that so much! The humor/snark/dialog absolutely made my day and I keep wanting to quote it. XD
3. Arbrook Huxley and Sylvester Carthage, y’all. THESE TWO. <3 You know how there are dynamic duos who are just the best, especially together? And you take their last names and squish ’em together into something iconic. Holmes and Watson. Spellsmith and Carver. Beaumont and Beasley. Well Carthage and Huxley are next on my list! I just love them and their friendship-not-friendship-whatever-it-is. Carthage is a slightly older man who’s a genius at making mechanical things and devising illusions to enchant a crowd, but he’s also got the heart of a child and is intensely introverted. I kind of related to that and he was so REAL. I love him. Then you have Huxley, who is... well... he’s Huxley! Young and dashing and energetic, he’s the smooth-talking and charismatic co-manager, and he's so funny, especially when paired with Carthage. XD They’re my favorite thing about this book. ^_^ But both have a lot to learn, and are hiding secrets, and nothing's going to work out until they learn to trust each other...
4. Welcome to the steampunk-ish, absolutely delightful, original world of the Celestial Isles, in which there are a string of “isles” floating above an ether sea with sky trains traveling between them. There are “electricals” (basically like robots) and I love the trains and the 1800s-esque feel. I feel like it’s such an enchanting world that it’s kind of like the best fantasy, but at the same time it’s more sci-fi/steampunk-ish, since there isn’t really anything “fantasy” or “magical” about it? Things are powered by electricity or stardust and just—everything’s so unique. I love it! It feels utterly magical without being real fantasy at all and... I can’t really describe it but I’m in love with the world. :P
5. The Electrical Menagerie (their show) is taking part in what is essentially a circus-type competition to put on the best show. Which means there’s a lot of imaginative, gorgeous acts going on, and I loved seeing what would happen next. But there’s also a murder mystery and sabotage going on and WHO IS BEHIND IT ALL? :O Because all Carthage and Huxley need on top of the competition is secret plots and danger, right? ;)
6. There are plot twists, too, and the book took a totally unexpected turn and just—whoa! It’s very edge-of-your-seat. The adventure’s exciting, and you know it’s awesome when, on top of trying to win a competition, there’s also a deep plot and a princess in danger and lots of potential for betrayal, and ALL the excitement. I read the whole book in a day because I couldn’t stop reading. :D
7. Aside from the wonderfulness that is Carthage and Huxley themselves, the other characters are fascinating too. I especially love Dominic the electrical butler! AAAHH. I love him so much. *feelz* His last speech in the book, though. It was... just... so touching and true. GAH.
8. This book made me laugh over and over—and, yes, it made me cry too. Like... I don’t know how it made me care that much but— *sniffles* THE FEELS. But I think I’m okay. Really. I don’t know why I cared so much but gaah. (It was still beautiful, though. :))
9. It taught me things about myself and life and deep things and—wow. Yes. I often find bits of unexpected truth in the most unlikely places, and I didn’t expect to find such soul-touching things in this super fun, swashbuckling, snarky story of two unlikely friends and their illusion show, but IT WAS THERE. It’s deep and touching even in the midst of the fun, and don’t you just love that? When a story is fun AND feelsy AND has depth AND it will just sweep you along in an utterly rollicking adventure? UGH, so good. *hugs book* It’s a clean read, too, and just so delightful.
10. Just—just—there is no way I can properly describe this book and how much I liked it, so I’m going to stop trying and just point you in the direction of the book itself. *points imperiously toward it* GO READ IT, PLEASE AND THANK YOU. AND YOU’RE WELCOME. (You can thank me later.) I need more adventures of Carthage and Huxley ASAP, and YOU, my friend, need to go read this one immediately. Ladies and gentlemen, that is all I have to say on this subject. Thank you, and good night. *bows*
I won an ARC ebook in a giveaway (thanks!) and wasn’t required to write a review. These opinions are my own.
(Also posted on my book blog: 10 Reasons You Should Read The Electrical Menagerie.)
1. What did I just read? *deep breath* I LOVED THIS BOOK. It was absolutely delightful and I have a book hangover—how will anything ever be this good again? AAHH. *collapses and wails and longs for a sequel* I don’t think I’ve ever read anything like this but it was INCREDIBLE and just so much fun! :D
2. The humor! It’s an utterly hilarious book and I LOVE that so much! The humor/snark/dialog absolutely made my day and I keep wanting to quote it. XD
3. Arbrook Huxley and Sylvester Carthage, y’all. THESE TWO. <3 You know how there are dynamic duos who are just the best, especially together? And you take their last names and squish ’em together into something iconic. Holmes and Watson. Spellsmith and Carver. Beaumont and Beasley. Well Carthage and Huxley are next on my list! I just love them and their friendship-not-friendship-whatever-it-is. Carthage is a slightly older man who’s a genius at making mechanical things and devising illusions to enchant a crowd, but he’s also got the heart of a child and is intensely introverted. I kind of related to that and he was so REAL. I love him. Then you have Huxley, who is... well... he’s Huxley! Young and dashing and energetic, he’s the smooth-talking and charismatic co-manager, and he's so funny, especially when paired with Carthage. XD They’re my favorite thing about this book. ^_^ But both have a lot to learn, and are hiding secrets, and nothing's going to work out until they learn to trust each other...
4. Welcome to the steampunk-ish, absolutely delightful, original world of the Celestial Isles, in which there are a string of “isles” floating above an ether sea with sky trains traveling between them. There are “electricals” (basically like robots) and I love the trains and the 1800s-esque feel. I feel like it’s such an enchanting world that it’s kind of like the best fantasy, but at the same time it’s more sci-fi/steampunk-ish, since there isn’t really anything “fantasy” or “magical” about it? Things are powered by electricity or stardust and just—everything’s so unique. I love it! It feels utterly magical without being real fantasy at all and... I can’t really describe it but I’m in love with the world. :P
5. The Electrical Menagerie (their show) is taking part in what is essentially a circus-type competition to put on the best show. Which means there’s a lot of imaginative, gorgeous acts going on, and I loved seeing what would happen next. But there’s also a murder mystery and sabotage going on and WHO IS BEHIND IT ALL? :O Because all Carthage and Huxley need on top of the competition is secret plots and danger, right? ;)
6. There are plot twists, too, and the book took a totally unexpected turn and just—whoa! It’s very edge-of-your-seat. The adventure’s exciting, and you know it’s awesome when, on top of trying to win a competition, there’s also a deep plot and a princess in danger and lots of potential for betrayal, and ALL the excitement. I read the whole book in a day because I couldn’t stop reading. :D
7. Aside from the wonderfulness that is Carthage and Huxley themselves, the other characters are fascinating too. I especially love Dominic the electrical butler! AAAHH. I love him so much. *feelz* His last speech in the book, though. It was... just... so touching and true. GAH.
8. This book made me laugh over and over—and, yes, it made me cry too. Like... I don’t know how it made me care that much but— *sniffles* THE FEELS. But I think I’m okay. Really. I don’t know why I cared so much but gaah. (It was still beautiful, though. :))
9. It taught me things about myself and life and deep things and—wow. Yes. I often find bits of unexpected truth in the most unlikely places, and I didn’t expect to find such soul-touching things in this super fun, swashbuckling, snarky story of two unlikely friends and their illusion show, but IT WAS THERE. It’s deep and touching even in the midst of the fun, and don’t you just love that? When a story is fun AND feelsy AND has depth AND it will just sweep you along in an utterly rollicking adventure? UGH, so good. *hugs book* It’s a clean read, too, and just so delightful.
10. Just—just—there is no way I can properly describe this book and how much I liked it, so I’m going to stop trying and just point you in the direction of the book itself. *points imperiously toward it* GO READ IT, PLEASE AND THANK YOU. AND YOU’RE WELCOME. (You can thank me later.) I need more adventures of Carthage and Huxley ASAP, and YOU, my friend, need to go read this one immediately. Ladies and gentlemen, that is all I have to say on this subject. Thank you, and good night. *bows*
I won an ARC ebook in a giveaway (thanks!) and wasn’t required to write a review. These opinions are my own.
Some Favorite Quotes
(I could quote the whole thing, plus most of my favorites are spoilers, but here are some excellent non-spoiler-y ones.)
“Are you still alive?” Dominic asked him finally.
“Am I alive?” Huxley turned to him. “Yes, I’m alive. Why would you ask that?”
“You were uncharacteristically motionless and quiet. I thought you might be dead.”
Huxley blew air through his teeth. “Did I make a terrible mistake, Dominic?”
“The probability is high. But you’d have to be more specific.”
“Thanks a lot.”
“You’re welcome,” Dominic said without a trace of irony.
“You look like you’ve been run over by a train,” she said.
“Oh,” he said, and scrambled to rake his fingers through his hair and fix the tuck of his shirt.
“No, no…” She bit her lip. “The look on your face.”
He drank from a silver flask, which he held out to Carthage.
Carthage gave him a disapproving look. While at work?
“It’s /coffee/,” said Huxley. “Stars, you’re worse than the nuns at boarding academy.”
Relenting, Carthage took the flask. He drank a swig and nearly choked.
“What’s wrong?”
“It’s /cold/.”
“Well, it’s been in my coat since this morning.”
Carthage wanted to spit the lingering traces out of his mouth, but that would have been improper. He swallowed his own grimace. “Don’t offer me anything that’s been in your coat since morning ever again.”
“You’re very talented, and I especially admire how collected you are in a crisis. Except for that time you broke a teacup on the floor. That wasn’t very collected.”
“Huxley… what’s wrong with you?”
“I was spiked with a truth serum which seems to have drastically lowered my inhibitions.” Huxley raised a confident hand. ��But it’s alright. I think it’s wearing off.”
“I’m quite certain it’s not,” said Carthage.
Huxley’s hand darted out, finger aimed at a scallop of frosting. Carthage slapped the hand away.
“What are you /doing/?” he hissed.
“I’m /so/ hungry,” Huxley said.
“You can’t steal food from the table of the Future Queen!”
“It’s not /stealing/!” Huxley hissed back. “My tax dollars paid for that cake!”
“If only my mother could see me now,” he said aloud.
“If /my/ mother could see me now,” said Huxley, “I’d be legally disowned.”
Secondly, the swarms of biting insects that came out in the early evening. Huxley called them mosquitoes and seemed unconcerned by them, even though they could bite you through your clothes and suck the blood out of your body, which seemed to Carthage like something to be concerned about.
August 8, 2020
VIDEO REVIEW HERE: https://youtu.be/D0OAA_dEmp4
An absolutely thrilling story!
I knew going in that this book was going to be phenomenal because I had seen glowing reviews and massive fangirling. Yet, I don't think this even fully prepared me for the magical journey and lovable characters!
Truly, The Electrical Menagerie was everything and more. I didn't know I needed it until I read it to be honest. Carthage and Huxley have I guess what would be called a "bromance" and quite sure the author had me stuffing my face with popcorn as I watched the drama unfold.
When I first started, I was reading at my dinner table during a Hurricane turned Tropical Storm, but somewhere in that time, I wasn't home. I was watching Carthage perform next to a young girl who was just as swept into this magical display as I was. And the amazing part is that it wasn't just the scenes of performances. No, it was scenes where you were sobbing while eating that popcorn I mentioned because restoration of dreams you didn't realize are blooming and unfolding in such a powerful way you can't help but smile a teary smile.
I very much want more of these characters. One moment I was saying how relatable Carthage was only to the next moment say how relatable Huxley was. Can I please just have tea with both? Oh, and with Dominic too?
Thank you, Miss Reeder, for bringing us readers such an imaginative tale that teleports into a new world and reminds us to not give up on our dreams.
A must read this 2018 year!
An absolutely thrilling story!
I knew going in that this book was going to be phenomenal because I had seen glowing reviews and massive fangirling. Yet, I don't think this even fully prepared me for the magical journey and lovable characters!
Truly, The Electrical Menagerie was everything and more. I didn't know I needed it until I read it to be honest. Carthage and Huxley have I guess what would be called a "bromance" and quite sure the author had me stuffing my face with popcorn as I watched the drama unfold.
When I first started, I was reading at my dinner table during a Hurricane turned Tropical Storm, but somewhere in that time, I wasn't home. I was watching Carthage perform next to a young girl who was just as swept into this magical display as I was. And the amazing part is that it wasn't just the scenes of performances. No, it was scenes where you were sobbing while eating that popcorn I mentioned because restoration of dreams you didn't realize are blooming and unfolding in such a powerful way you can't help but smile a teary smile.
I very much want more of these characters. One moment I was saying how relatable Carthage was only to the next moment say how relatable Huxley was. Can I please just have tea with both? Oh, and with Dominic too?
Thank you, Miss Reeder, for bringing us readers such an imaginative tale that teleports into a new world and reminds us to not give up on our dreams.
A must read this 2018 year!
April 9, 2018
The Electrical Menagerie is difficult to classify--in an awesome way. It doesn't fit perfectly into the sci-fi or fantasy genres, but instead bridges the two. It's set in a rich and captivating universe with many steampunk elements--though "steampunk" is too simplistic a term to fully describe it. It's a realm of flat islands floating in space, stars that orbit the "earth," and mechanical wonders that border on the magical. All that was enough to suck me in right from the outset, but even the most fascinating fictional universes aren't enough to make a story work if the characters aren't engaging enough. Fortunately, The Electrical Menagerie does not have this problem.
At the center of the tale are showman/inventor Sylvester Carthage and his manager, Arbrook Huxley. There's a refreshingly unique friendship between them. Though Carthage is a child at heart, hungry for wonder and adventure but occasionally hampered by social anxiety, he's the older member of the duo (middle-aged, to be more precise). Huxley is in his twenties, but he has a gruff, practical nature. Both characters are fleshed out in detail right from the start, and their fun, frequently-hilarious dynamic makes the book a joy to read. (There's a lot of laugh-out-loud, Pratchett-esque humor in between the more suspenseful moments.)
The peripheral characters are excellent as well...and here's where I'm forced to become vague, because there's a truly brilliant mystery woven into this story that should definitely not be spoiled. I don't think I can say much about the supporting cast without letting details slip. Suffice it to say that all the characterization is excellent--and that Ms. Reeder has a unique talent for nailing a mystery. I usually guess the solution to such storylines well before the end, but the truth behind the "accidents" plaguing the contest Carthage and Huxley enter took me completely by surprise. At the same time, however, it made perfect sense, and set up a conclusion that was both thrilling and satisfying. The ending leaves plenty of room for future stories, but it's not a cliffhanger. The book feels like a complete, stand-alone story. At the same time, however, you'll be eager to read more of the adventures of Carthage and Huxley once you've finished. (Fortunately, more are on the way!)
So, going down the list--amazing storyworld, delightful characters, and mind-blowing mystery. Are you excited yet?
The Electrical Menagerie is one of the most enjoyable books I've read in a long time. Mollie Reeder is definitely an author to keep on your radar. She's created the kind of universe and characters that fandoms are built on. Don't miss out--you owe it to yourself to get in on The Celestial Isles.
At the center of the tale are showman/inventor Sylvester Carthage and his manager, Arbrook Huxley. There's a refreshingly unique friendship between them. Though Carthage is a child at heart, hungry for wonder and adventure but occasionally hampered by social anxiety, he's the older member of the duo (middle-aged, to be more precise). Huxley is in his twenties, but he has a gruff, practical nature. Both characters are fleshed out in detail right from the start, and their fun, frequently-hilarious dynamic makes the book a joy to read. (There's a lot of laugh-out-loud, Pratchett-esque humor in between the more suspenseful moments.)
The peripheral characters are excellent as well...and here's where I'm forced to become vague, because there's a truly brilliant mystery woven into this story that should definitely not be spoiled. I don't think I can say much about the supporting cast without letting details slip. Suffice it to say that all the characterization is excellent--and that Ms. Reeder has a unique talent for nailing a mystery. I usually guess the solution to such storylines well before the end, but the truth behind the "accidents" plaguing the contest Carthage and Huxley enter took me completely by surprise. At the same time, however, it made perfect sense, and set up a conclusion that was both thrilling and satisfying. The ending leaves plenty of room for future stories, but it's not a cliffhanger. The book feels like a complete, stand-alone story. At the same time, however, you'll be eager to read more of the adventures of Carthage and Huxley once you've finished. (Fortunately, more are on the way!)
So, going down the list--amazing storyworld, delightful characters, and mind-blowing mystery. Are you excited yet?
The Electrical Menagerie is one of the most enjoyable books I've read in a long time. Mollie Reeder is definitely an author to keep on your radar. She's created the kind of universe and characters that fandoms are built on. Don't miss out--you owe it to yourself to get in on The Celestial Isles.
March 28, 2019
I went into this book without lofty expectations because the genre and subject matter weren't ones I would typically be drawn to. To be honest, so many friends had praised it that I was mostly curious to see for myself.
Having finished it for myself, I can now say one thing for certain: The Electrical Menagerie is flawless.
The pacing from start to finish, the character arcs, the intrigue, the writing*, the sense of purpose infused into every scene and beat. Are there minor nits to be picked? Maybe. Very few, and all of them subjective. But the story is so confident in its own skin that I can't be bothered to waste review space on them.
Not only that, but for all my hesitations regarding genre and subject matter (since when do I read about robotic roadshows?), The Electrical Menagerie has everything I look for in a book: characters with deep, meaningful connections; chapters that aren't afraid to slow down and give the cast room to breathe; themes that are woven into the story without being preachy; an ending that takes the time to do its job well.
*Can we talk about the writing for a moment? I'm thoroughly impressed. There's such rich vocabulary embedded into the writing that it makes the story come to life even more, and yet the style is so effortless to read. Not once does the dialog feel cringe-worthy or plot-serving, and it's all so...balanced. Regarding execution and technique, this is, without a doubt, the best indie book I've ever read.
I'm very pleased (and still somewhat surprised) that The Electrical Menagerie is my first full five-star read since...well, let's say it's been some time. You guys know how frugal I am with five star reviews, but I can't honestly justify anything lower. Well done!
Having finished it for myself, I can now say one thing for certain: The Electrical Menagerie is flawless.
The pacing from start to finish, the character arcs, the intrigue, the writing*, the sense of purpose infused into every scene and beat. Are there minor nits to be picked? Maybe. Very few, and all of them subjective. But the story is so confident in its own skin that I can't be bothered to waste review space on them.
Not only that, but for all my hesitations regarding genre and subject matter (since when do I read about robotic roadshows?), The Electrical Menagerie has everything I look for in a book: characters with deep, meaningful connections; chapters that aren't afraid to slow down and give the cast room to breathe; themes that are woven into the story without being preachy; an ending that takes the time to do its job well.
*Can we talk about the writing for a moment? I'm thoroughly impressed. There's such rich vocabulary embedded into the writing that it makes the story come to life even more, and yet the style is so effortless to read. Not once does the dialog feel cringe-worthy or plot-serving, and it's all so...balanced. Regarding execution and technique, this is, without a doubt, the best indie book I've ever read.
I'm very pleased (and still somewhat surprised) that The Electrical Menagerie is my first full five-star read since...well, let's say it's been some time. You guys know how frugal I am with five star reviews, but I can't honestly justify anything lower. Well done!
September 30, 2018
Finally read this!! It was a lovely way to spend a Sunday afternoon and it very much lived up to the hype. ;)
I think the coolest part for me was all the electricals and illusions. Some part of me is very fascinated with magic tricks and illusions, though I just want to be impressed and not so much figure out how they work. Carthage would have a very willing audience in me. lol!
But Huxley is still my fave. I think it's because I read the prequel novella first and found him to be adorkably charming. What can I say?
Super fun book with engaging characters and premise! Looking forward to more of their shenanigans!
I think the coolest part for me was all the electricals and illusions. Some part of me is very fascinated with magic tricks and illusions, though I just want to be impressed and not so much figure out how they work. Carthage would have a very willing audience in me. lol!
But Huxley is still my fave. I think it's because I read the prequel novella first and found him to be adorkably charming. What can I say?
Super fun book with engaging characters and premise! Looking forward to more of their shenanigans!
August 12, 2019
Man, this book is INCREDIBLE. Awesome world-building, the perfect mix of character-driven and plot-driven. The disability representation was so, so good. I almost exploded from happiness. Also: the audiobook narrator is brilliant. I loved every single aspect of this novel and cannot recommend it highly enough.
March 17, 2019
What an absolutely gorgeous story.
March 27, 2019
I was so excited when this book released on audiobook! It has been on my TBR for a while, but I don't have a lot of time to sit down and read books these days. So when it became available on audiobook, I immediately purchased it and started listening a few days later.
The narrator did a really good job. At first I wasn't sure if I was going to like him, but then I got used to his voice and couldn't stop listening.
After hearing so much about this book and so much fangirling, I went into this book kind of cautiously, afraid it wouldn't live up to the hype.
The beginning starts fairly slow and mild. It focuses on a steampunk/electrical circus show that is on the brink of disaster. They enter a contest as a last ditch effort to save their show.
The contest part of the book was interesting. A lot of set up and build up and some mysteries and dangers. But it wasn't until about halfway through the book when it really took off for me and things really became heart pounding.
The steampunk/electrical invention part of the book was my favorite. It was so inventive and fun, and that was where the real wonder of the book came from.
I liked how this book could function as a standalone. The main storyline is wrapped up, so don't hold off on reading this book because you don't want a cliffhanger ending.
I enjoyed this book and I'm really excited to see what the author has for other books in this series!
The narrator did a really good job. At first I wasn't sure if I was going to like him, but then I got used to his voice and couldn't stop listening.
After hearing so much about this book and so much fangirling, I went into this book kind of cautiously, afraid it wouldn't live up to the hype.
The beginning starts fairly slow and mild. It focuses on a steampunk/electrical circus show that is on the brink of disaster. They enter a contest as a last ditch effort to save their show.
The contest part of the book was interesting. A lot of set up and build up and some mysteries and dangers. But it wasn't until about halfway through the book when it really took off for me and things really became heart pounding.
The steampunk/electrical invention part of the book was my favorite. It was so inventive and fun, and that was where the real wonder of the book came from.
I liked how this book could function as a standalone. The main storyline is wrapped up, so don't hold off on reading this book because you don't want a cliffhanger ending.
I enjoyed this book and I'm really excited to see what the author has for other books in this series!
April 30, 2019
I just had the most delightful experience!
It’s somehow fitting that a story largely involved with theatrical performance should be brought to life in this way by a talented audio performer. It was wonderfully theatrical to listen to—the next best thing to seeing it on a screen. I LOVED it!
It’s a wild ride of adventure, imagination, flying trains and islands in the sky, electrical robots, a stardust-powered steampunk-feel, show-business and illusions, mystery and sabotage and insidious plots, an 1800s-feel, and one of my favorite things: a “buddy story.”
Mollie Reeder’s skillful tale is a story to touch the heart of any creative and anyone who’s ever dreamed of doing something MORE. It’s one of the most sheerly enjoyable books I’ve ever read, but it also has a depth to it that makes you re-examine life and learn new things about life and ourselves, through the adventures of these delightful characters who are wholly human—both making mistakes and committing feats of imagination and heroism. It inspires me to reach for the stars. And it makes me laugh, which is always important. ;)
I read The Electrical Menagerie when it first came out, and it joined the select ranks of one of my favorite books of all time. So to say I was excited for the chance to re-experience it, as an audiobook, is an understatement.
I started the audio version with caution, however. Would any rendition of this beloved book be able to do it justice?
But I needn’t have worried. While I still may prefer reading physical books, this audiobook was a sheer delight! I had SUCH a blast listening to it! It was like revisiting an old friend and it came alive anew. ^_^
Travis Baldree’s rendition of these larger-than-life characters was wonderful and I 100% enjoyed hearing them all come to life! The different accents were great fun (I particularly liked Miss Skyhawk's voice) and Carthage and Huxley re-delighted me all over again! I was constantly smiling or laughing, even on this second reading. The other characters are incredible too, and the dramatic or exciting scenes soared.
I LOVE this book and Carthage and Huxley, who are both absolutely AWESOME characters in their totally different ways, and the sheer rich imagination of everything about The Electrical Menagerie.
This book gives me ALL THE FEELS. It made me laugh and it made me cry, in both its book and audiobook forms. (Now THAT is a feat.) I love the humor and the heart of it, how authentic and real it is—despite, or perhaps because of, the otherwordliness of it—touching the soul, but not in any artificial way, while making one smile.
I didn’t used to listen to many audiobooks but I’ve slowly been drawn into that world, and now I love them. It was fabulous to get to re-live this magnificent story while going about daily life.
I can only say that The Electrical Menagerie is an EXPERIENCE. “I'm Arbrook Huxley”—(er . . . Deborah O'Carroll)—“and you can quote me!” (All I need now is a sequel. ;))
I love that this book is now available in a new format to delight new readers—or should I say listeners? I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone who needs a touch of stardust and wonder in their lives!
(Thanks to the author for the complimentary audiobook code. All opinions are 100% my own.)
Review also posted on my book blog, here.
Read my original review here.
It’s somehow fitting that a story largely involved with theatrical performance should be brought to life in this way by a talented audio performer. It was wonderfully theatrical to listen to—the next best thing to seeing it on a screen. I LOVED it!
It’s a wild ride of adventure, imagination, flying trains and islands in the sky, electrical robots, a stardust-powered steampunk-feel, show-business and illusions, mystery and sabotage and insidious plots, an 1800s-feel, and one of my favorite things: a “buddy story.”
Mollie Reeder’s skillful tale is a story to touch the heart of any creative and anyone who’s ever dreamed of doing something MORE. It’s one of the most sheerly enjoyable books I’ve ever read, but it also has a depth to it that makes you re-examine life and learn new things about life and ourselves, through the adventures of these delightful characters who are wholly human—both making mistakes and committing feats of imagination and heroism. It inspires me to reach for the stars. And it makes me laugh, which is always important. ;)
I read The Electrical Menagerie when it first came out, and it joined the select ranks of one of my favorite books of all time. So to say I was excited for the chance to re-experience it, as an audiobook, is an understatement.
I started the audio version with caution, however. Would any rendition of this beloved book be able to do it justice?
But I needn’t have worried. While I still may prefer reading physical books, this audiobook was a sheer delight! I had SUCH a blast listening to it! It was like revisiting an old friend and it came alive anew. ^_^
Travis Baldree’s rendition of these larger-than-life characters was wonderful and I 100% enjoyed hearing them all come to life! The different accents were great fun (I particularly liked Miss Skyhawk's voice) and Carthage and Huxley re-delighted me all over again! I was constantly smiling or laughing, even on this second reading. The other characters are incredible too, and the dramatic or exciting scenes soared.
I LOVE this book and Carthage and Huxley, who are both absolutely AWESOME characters in their totally different ways, and the sheer rich imagination of everything about The Electrical Menagerie.
This book gives me ALL THE FEELS. It made me laugh and it made me cry, in both its book and audiobook forms. (Now THAT is a feat.) I love the humor and the heart of it, how authentic and real it is—despite, or perhaps because of, the otherwordliness of it—touching the soul, but not in any artificial way, while making one smile.
I didn’t used to listen to many audiobooks but I’ve slowly been drawn into that world, and now I love them. It was fabulous to get to re-live this magnificent story while going about daily life.
I can only say that The Electrical Menagerie is an EXPERIENCE. “I'm Arbrook Huxley”—(er . . . Deborah O'Carroll)—“and you can quote me!” (All I need now is a sequel. ;))
I love that this book is now available in a new format to delight new readers—or should I say listeners? I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone who needs a touch of stardust and wonder in their lives!
(Thanks to the author for the complimentary audiobook code. All opinions are 100% my own.)
Review also posted on my book blog, here.
Read my original review here.
June 9, 2018
4.5 Stars!
This book was a delightful romp! Huxley and Carthage are so lifelike, they jump off the page, and they have some surprising complexities to their characters. For instance, I found it fascinating how Carthage was a bit of an absent-minded genius who absolutely thrived on performance but is painfully shy in other social settings. It seemed like some of these elements of his character should contradict, but they don't. Huxley in turn, for all his appearance of worldliness, is rather vulnerable and naive.
The prose was light and airy, the dialogue charming and hilarious. And I felt the book was wrapped up remarkably well, leaving me satisfied and a bit nostalgic.
There were just a few places along the way that I struggled with minor issues that may be personal taste (scenes too short, conversations out of character etc). But really they were all very, very small.
I loved this book overall and definitely recommend that everyone check it out! And I am eagerly looking forward to more from Mollie E. Reeder.
This book was a delightful romp! Huxley and Carthage are so lifelike, they jump off the page, and they have some surprising complexities to their characters. For instance, I found it fascinating how Carthage was a bit of an absent-minded genius who absolutely thrived on performance but is painfully shy in other social settings. It seemed like some of these elements of his character should contradict, but they don't. Huxley in turn, for all his appearance of worldliness, is rather vulnerable and naive.
The prose was light and airy, the dialogue charming and hilarious. And I felt the book was wrapped up remarkably well, leaving me satisfied and a bit nostalgic.
There were just a few places along the way that I struggled with minor issues that may be personal taste (scenes too short, conversations out of character etc). But really they were all very, very small.
I loved this book overall and definitely recommend that everyone check it out! And I am eagerly looking forward to more from Mollie E. Reeder.
May 17, 2018
A delightful steampunk fantasy tale as entertaining and whimsical as it is startlingly thought-provoking and profound. A must-read!
September 15, 2018
4.5
This felt fresh and original. The steampunk world was enchanting and entertaining. I liked how the friendship grew between the main characters and the murder mystery aspect of the plot kept me turning the pages (although no huge surprises in that direction). This had a literary feel with themes such as illusion verses honesty and the necessity of confronting the past to heal the present. There’s a lot of funny one-liners too. Overall this is an entertaining read but with heart and depth.
(Huxley, I hope you appreciate this slice of bread).
This felt fresh and original. The steampunk world was enchanting and entertaining. I liked how the friendship grew between the main characters and the murder mystery aspect of the plot kept me turning the pages (although no huge surprises in that direction). This had a literary feel with themes such as illusion verses honesty and the necessity of confronting the past to heal the present. There’s a lot of funny one-liners too. Overall this is an entertaining read but with heart and depth.
(Huxley, I hope you appreciate this slice of bread).
July 28, 2022
Purely delightful. Review to come.
March 12, 2023
Truly a beautifully-written, stardust-sprinkled, high-stakes adventure with a vibrant world and lively characters.
June 18, 2019
I WANT TO READ FIFTY MORE CELESTIAL ISLES BOOKS!!!
The story world is fun and fascinating, but it never upstages the real STARS of this book--Carthage and Huxley. These two are gold. Compelling and real as individuals, they're just alike enough and just different enough to really light up the page when they're together. Each dealing with his own past heartaches and traumas, there is so much growth and depth and new, precarious friendship in these pages! And robots! I just loved it all the way around. Entertaining and well-told and occasionally profound. This is definitely a read-again book.
I am SO excited there's going to be a sequel. I am hooked.
The story world is fun and fascinating, but it never upstages the real STARS of this book--Carthage and Huxley. These two are gold. Compelling and real as individuals, they're just alike enough and just different enough to really light up the page when they're together. Each dealing with his own past heartaches and traumas, there is so much growth and depth and new, precarious friendship in these pages! And robots! I just loved it all the way around. Entertaining and well-told and occasionally profound. This is definitely a read-again book.
I am SO excited there's going to be a sequel. I am hooked.
August 12, 2019
This was such a delightful read and everything I hoped it would be. It swept me off my feet from the very first chapter and carried me off into a world I was sad to say goodbye to by the end. It has immediately become one of my favorite fantasy books and may just be the best book I’ve read so far this year.
The Electrical Menagerie follows dual protagonists Sylvester Carthage and Arbrook Huxley as they stake everything to compete in a talent competition in the hopes of saving their failing business. In many ways, the two characters are polar opposites, which is what makes all their interactions so fun and interesting to watch. Despite having gone into business together, each seems intent on keeping the other at a distance and protecting their own secrets, adding an extra layer of mystery to the book. Both characters are so well-developed that they seem to spring to life right off the page, with complex histories and motivations that kept me fully engaged with them as the story progressed. Other characters are also well-developed and pulled me further into the story. I especially liked Andromeda Skyhawke and hope to see her again at some point in future books.
The setting is fantastic, and for me struck the perfect balance of feeling like a living, breathing world without an over-reliance on extensive descriptions. Blending steampunk and magic and even some scientific elements, it felt like a place I would have been perfectly happy to explore and even live in for a while. The visuals are stunning, and I was truly impressed by the amount of care and detail that went into creating the Celestial Isles and all the magic of the Electrical Menagerie’s performances. I also really appreciated the balance the story struck between some of its more serious subject matter and the fun, lighthearted atmosphere that made it such a joy. It’s a bleak world out there, even in fiction, and it’s nice to read a story once in a while that brings such a brightness and hopefulness in spite of the challenges characters have to endure.
I’ll stop there, mostly because I just don’t know all the words to express how much I loved this book. It was amazing, seriously, and if you think it looks even remotely interesting, you should give it a read. I can’t wait for more.
The Electrical Menagerie follows dual protagonists Sylvester Carthage and Arbrook Huxley as they stake everything to compete in a talent competition in the hopes of saving their failing business. In many ways, the two characters are polar opposites, which is what makes all their interactions so fun and interesting to watch. Despite having gone into business together, each seems intent on keeping the other at a distance and protecting their own secrets, adding an extra layer of mystery to the book. Both characters are so well-developed that they seem to spring to life right off the page, with complex histories and motivations that kept me fully engaged with them as the story progressed. Other characters are also well-developed and pulled me further into the story. I especially liked Andromeda Skyhawke and hope to see her again at some point in future books.
The setting is fantastic, and for me struck the perfect balance of feeling like a living, breathing world without an over-reliance on extensive descriptions. Blending steampunk and magic and even some scientific elements, it felt like a place I would have been perfectly happy to explore and even live in for a while. The visuals are stunning, and I was truly impressed by the amount of care and detail that went into creating the Celestial Isles and all the magic of the Electrical Menagerie’s performances. I also really appreciated the balance the story struck between some of its more serious subject matter and the fun, lighthearted atmosphere that made it such a joy. It’s a bleak world out there, even in fiction, and it’s nice to read a story once in a while that brings such a brightness and hopefulness in spite of the challenges characters have to endure.
I’ll stop there, mostly because I just don’t know all the words to express how much I loved this book. It was amazing, seriously, and if you think it looks even remotely interesting, you should give it a read. I can’t wait for more.
October 6, 2019
Without a doubt, the best aspect of The Electrical Menagerie for me was the number of genres that it juggles so seamlessly. The Electrical Menagerie is an endlessly entertaining mix of sci-fi, murder mystery, competition narrative (think perhaps of Monsters University or Pitch Perfect), political thriller, and buddy comedy. You would think that any story with its hands in so many cookie jars would end up feeling rather disjointed. But Reeder pulls it off seemly. The Electrical Menagerie doesn’t even feel like a mix of genres so much as its own thing.
I will admit that I somehow felt like I didn’t get to know the main characters quite as well as I might have liked to (which is odd because I’m not really sure what could have been done better; the characters are certainly well developed). Still, Huxley and Cartridge are most definitely strong characters. They have great-backstories. I liked them both, and their friendship is endearing.
And can I just say that the prose was impeccable? Even listening to the audio-book, I could tell this.
For once, I don’t really have that much to say about an indie-book. Objectively, it is one of the best self-published novels I have ever read. The Malfunction and the Get in my Head series are the only ones that probably compare. While subjectively I wouldn’t rank it quite that high, I definitely enjoyed it and can’t wait to get my hands on the sequels!
I will admit that I somehow felt like I didn’t get to know the main characters quite as well as I might have liked to (which is odd because I’m not really sure what could have been done better; the characters are certainly well developed). Still, Huxley and Cartridge are most definitely strong characters. They have great-backstories. I liked them both, and their friendship is endearing.
And can I just say that the prose was impeccable? Even listening to the audio-book, I could tell this.
For once, I don’t really have that much to say about an indie-book. Objectively, it is one of the best self-published novels I have ever read. The Malfunction and the Get in my Head series are the only ones that probably compare. While subjectively I wouldn’t rank it quite that high, I definitely enjoyed it and can’t wait to get my hands on the sequels!
February 8, 2019
Loved this book! It made me smile and laugh and want to read it again as soon I finished the first time. The Electrical Menagerie has such a fascinating story world and premise – an almost bankrupt robotic roadshow (robots on the stage, how cool is that???) participates in a grand contest where a series of auditions will select one show to perform before royalty – and it’s told with such strong, vivid writing that I could visualize each scene as if it was playing out before me on the big screen.
And while all of that is awesome, the BEST part really was the characters! Carthage and Huxley are both so relatable, so witty, and so DARLING, that you really do just want to hug them as the stress of auditioning tests their business partnership and friendship and as the conflict backstage between the participating shows grows more and more deadly.
In short, with intrigue and dastardly plots, electronic butlers, flying trains, and so much more, it's an exciting story full of wonder and magic (and murder ... gasp), and I'm just dying for Book Two!
And while all of that is awesome, the BEST part really was the characters! Carthage and Huxley are both so relatable, so witty, and so DARLING, that you really do just want to hug them as the stress of auditioning tests their business partnership and friendship and as the conflict backstage between the participating shows grows more and more deadly.
In short, with intrigue and dastardly plots, electronic butlers, flying trains, and so much more, it's an exciting story full of wonder and magic (and murder ... gasp), and I'm just dying for Book Two!
March 3, 2020
This book was entirely delightful! Beautifully written, with an engaging plot and complex, subtly drawn characters, The Electrical Menagerie is the kind of book that gives indie publishing a good name. I loved the imaginative-yet-familiar story world, the steampunk-flavoured setting, the twists and turns in the plot, the bromance between the two main characters, and pretty much everything else. My only niggle was the ending, which didn't quite live up to everything else for me, but you know, that's also a complaint I had about Avatar: The Last Airbender, so in conclusion: read it.
August 22, 2018
I loved it. Best vacation read ever, and Carthage and Huxley were SUCH fun friends. I can't wait to read more from this author!
August 31, 2019
*jaw drops*
My goodness! This book was just about everything I hoped, nothing that I feared, and more than I expected simultaneously. Wow--just wow!
To start with, the setting was so cool! The blend of steampunk and sci-fi with a nonmagical fantasy world was so unique and amazingly well done. It absolutely popped off the page and made me feel like I was right there. Also, it made me feel grounded in what was going on without massive info dumps or long digressions on history, politics, science, etc. That's so hard to do, but it was done so well! Can I tell you exactly what the Terraformists stand for, or when they were founded, or...basically anything substantial about them? Nope, not really. But I automatically feel a bit frightened when I hear they're plotting something. Do I have any clue what the properties of stardust are, or exactly what it's capable of? Absolutely not. But please be careful with that barrel over there... Absolutely stellar job! (Pun only halfway intended. :D)
I started out unsure of where exactly the plot was going to go and ended up with my heart in my throat for at least a good half of the book. I did make a couple of good guesses, but not nearly all of them. Things did seem to slow down a bit near the end--I think just because the character stuff wrapped up so early--which made the big plot climax feel a bit like a denouement. But I was actually really glad that the character drama was brought to a head and resolved as fast as it was, so not a huge complaint for me. The way things wrapped up for one certain character did leave me a bit sad, but overall, I really liked the resolution.
Okay, now we get to characters. Which I purposely saved for last because...eeeeeeek!!! The characters!!! They were my absolute favorite part of the book! Every time I laughed or gasped or put my hand over my heart (which happened a lot), it was 100% because of the characters. Also, my reaction to the characters was not quite the one I was expecting to have, which surprised and intrigued me. From the very beginning, I liked Carthage, felt for him, identified with him--but for some reason it took a few chapters before he completely grabbed hold of my heart. (Don't worry, he's firmly and fully there now; it just took a little longer than I expected to get that spark.) On the other hand, Huxley, who I fully expected to take a while to warm up to, somehow had me completely and helplessly in the palm of his hand from the word go. Brash, cocky, rough-around-the-edges characters are usually not my favorites, but those tiny flashes of vulnerability beneath the self-assured facade? I was absolutely gone. I adored the way they eventually opened up and came together, even if getting there felt as painful for me as it was for them sometimes. And the little ways you could see that they did legitimately care for each other even before they really understood each other, and the way they discovered how much stronger they were as a team...my heart is so happy. <3<3
There were a lot of great messages in this book, but I think the one that resonated with me the most strongly was the one Carthage was faced with in a few scenes, about needing real, genuine human interaction and not trying to be in control of every encounter. No, I've never created an electrical for companionship, but I do sometimes hide behind the written word, where I can carefully shape the image people see of me, without all the embarrassing stumbles and uncertainty. Definitely a lesson I need to keep in mind.
About the only thing that made me at all uncomfortable were a few of the rougher edges to Huxley's character, although even those were pretty tamed down from what they could have been. Specifically, the "in-world" swearing (expressions like "stars"), which wouldn't even warrant a mention if it weren't for the fact that it's specifically called swearing and corrected by other characters. There are also mentions of some serious misconduct in his past, which are not addressed outright, although they're addressed indirectly and never condoned. But other than that, there's really nothing that gave me pause. Also, I appreciated the fact that even though there's no direct salvation message, Carthage's religion seems very solidly Christian (set within their world, but not some weird fantasy remake) and is woven into his thoughts and actions throughout the book.
Overall, I really, really enjoyed this story and am eagerly looking forward to more adventures on the Celestial Isles!
Content--fighting, including gunplay; various accidents, wounds and death ; mentions of drinking and drunkenness; mentions of gambling; mentions of various types of cheating, foul play, bribery, etc.; in-world "swearing" (see above); mentions of worshiping stars and using them to tell the future (portrayed as false); mentions of "magic" in the context of illusions
My goodness! This book was just about everything I hoped, nothing that I feared, and more than I expected simultaneously. Wow--just wow!
To start with, the setting was so cool! The blend of steampunk and sci-fi with a nonmagical fantasy world was so unique and amazingly well done. It absolutely popped off the page and made me feel like I was right there. Also, it made me feel grounded in what was going on without massive info dumps or long digressions on history, politics, science, etc. That's so hard to do, but it was done so well! Can I tell you exactly what the Terraformists stand for, or when they were founded, or...basically anything substantial about them? Nope, not really. But I automatically feel a bit frightened when I hear they're plotting something. Do I have any clue what the properties of stardust are, or exactly what it's capable of? Absolutely not. But please be careful with that barrel over there... Absolutely stellar job! (Pun only halfway intended. :D)
I started out unsure of where exactly the plot was going to go and ended up with my heart in my throat for at least a good half of the book. I did make a couple of good guesses, but not nearly all of them. Things did seem to slow down a bit near the end--I think just because the character stuff wrapped up so early--which made the big plot climax feel a bit like a denouement. But I was actually really glad that the character drama was brought to a head and resolved as fast as it was, so not a huge complaint for me. The way things wrapped up for one certain character did leave me a bit sad, but overall, I really liked the resolution.
Okay, now we get to characters. Which I purposely saved for last because...eeeeeeek!!! The characters!!! They were my absolute favorite part of the book! Every time I laughed or gasped or put my hand over my heart (which happened a lot), it was 100% because of the characters. Also, my reaction to the characters was not quite the one I was expecting to have, which surprised and intrigued me. From the very beginning, I liked Carthage, felt for him, identified with him--but for some reason it took a few chapters before he completely grabbed hold of my heart. (Don't worry, he's firmly and fully there now; it just took a little longer than I expected to get that spark.) On the other hand, Huxley, who I fully expected to take a while to warm up to, somehow had me completely and helplessly in the palm of his hand from the word go. Brash, cocky, rough-around-the-edges characters are usually not my favorites, but those tiny flashes of vulnerability beneath the self-assured facade? I was absolutely gone. I adored the way they eventually opened up and came together, even if getting there felt as painful for me as it was for them sometimes. And the little ways you could see that they did legitimately care for each other even before they really understood each other, and the way they discovered how much stronger they were as a team...my heart is so happy. <3<3
There were a lot of great messages in this book, but I think the one that resonated with me the most strongly was the one Carthage was faced with in a few scenes, about needing real, genuine human interaction and not trying to be in control of every encounter. No, I've never created an electrical for companionship, but I do sometimes hide behind the written word, where I can carefully shape the image people see of me, without all the embarrassing stumbles and uncertainty. Definitely a lesson I need to keep in mind.
About the only thing that made me at all uncomfortable were a few of the rougher edges to Huxley's character, although even those were pretty tamed down from what they could have been. Specifically, the "in-world" swearing (expressions like "stars"), which wouldn't even warrant a mention if it weren't for the fact that it's specifically called swearing and corrected by other characters. There are also mentions of some serious misconduct in his past, which are not addressed outright, although they're addressed indirectly and never condoned. But other than that, there's really nothing that gave me pause. Also, I appreciated the fact that even though there's no direct salvation message, Carthage's religion seems very solidly Christian (set within their world, but not some weird fantasy remake) and is woven into his thoughts and actions throughout the book.
Overall, I really, really enjoyed this story and am eagerly looking forward to more adventures on the Celestial Isles!
Content--fighting, including gunplay; various accidents, wounds and death ; mentions of drinking and drunkenness; mentions of gambling; mentions of various types of cheating, foul play, bribery, etc.; in-world "swearing" (see above); mentions of worshiping stars and using them to tell the future (portrayed as false); mentions of "magic" in the context of illusions
July 8, 2019
Where do I start with this book? I haven't read a lot of steampunk stories, but this one came with such glowing recommendations from friends I trust that I had to check it out. I completely fell in love. The characters are engaging, the story is fun, and the writing superb. I loved how it was both exciting and mysterious and I always looked forward to the next time I'd get to read it. Carthage and Huxley were great main characters, lovable, and both so dynamic with so much growth. I appreciated how different they were and yet how they worked so well together. The contrast of one being older and one being younger was refreshing as well, since so many books tend toward younger main characters only. It was great to see their friendship change and grow over the course of the story, and to see them learn from each other. They are new additions on my list of favorite characters I can't get enough of. The side characters were also well developed. I appreciated that all of them had some role to play, and some of them surprised me with exactly what role they played. There was even one robot that I got very attached to and was sad when something happened to him. It takes great writing to make me cry over a robot! Speaking of great writing, I love how this author handles descriptions. I could picture all the action so clearly, both the exciting things and the beautiful ones. (Electrical, performing, butterflies need to be a real thing! C'mon, people, surely we have the technology to do this!)
Another thing I loved about this book were the themes. So many lovely themes, so expertly woven into the fabric of the story. I especially appreciated the themes of friendship, overcoming personal obstacles, and forgiveness.
I don't know what else to say besides, I loved this so much and can't wait to read more from this author!
Content Advisory:
Language:
All "swears" are made up words that fit with the world building, like "starfall".
Sexual:
Huxley is attracted to a pretty female magician and attempts to pursue her. They talk and flirt a little and go on one date. Nothing sexual happens.
Huxley tries to teach Carthage how to be better with the ladies at a party, but again, none of it is sexual.
Alcohol/Drugs:
Wine is drunk in social settings. (A fancy party and celebratory meal.)
Someone is drugged with a truth serum.
Violence:
A dead body has a gash in the forehead. Brief mention of blood.
Animals get poisoned enough to make them sick but not to kill them.
Action violence includes someone almost getting crushed by a falling light, someone almost getting strangled, someone getting hit in the face with a cane, and someone getting knocked unconscious and tossed around. A couple robots get shot with bullets. One robot gets crushed under debris and its "death" is a little sad. Some people get threatened with guns a couple times. Some people punch and wrestle each other. Someone falls from a height, but isn't hurt. A young girl is threatened with kidnapping and possible harm.
Spiritual:
God and Carthage's faith in God are mentioned a few times. The origin story for the world in which the story is set is briefly addressed and it resembles the creation story for our world.
There's mention that a lot of people in that world have beliefs that resemble astrology, thinking the stars somehow govern their fates.
Another thing I loved about this book were the themes. So many lovely themes, so expertly woven into the fabric of the story. I especially appreciated the themes of friendship, overcoming personal obstacles, and forgiveness.
I don't know what else to say besides, I loved this so much and can't wait to read more from this author!
Content Advisory:
Language:
All "swears" are made up words that fit with the world building, like "starfall".
Sexual:
Huxley is attracted to a pretty female magician and attempts to pursue her. They talk and flirt a little and go on one date. Nothing sexual happens.
Huxley tries to teach Carthage how to be better with the ladies at a party, but again, none of it is sexual.
Alcohol/Drugs:
Wine is drunk in social settings. (A fancy party and celebratory meal.)
Someone is drugged with a truth serum.
Violence:
A dead body has a gash in the forehead. Brief mention of blood.
Animals get poisoned enough to make them sick but not to kill them.
Action violence includes someone almost getting crushed by a falling light, someone almost getting strangled, someone getting hit in the face with a cane, and someone getting knocked unconscious and tossed around. A couple robots get shot with bullets. One robot gets crushed under debris and its "death" is a little sad. Some people get threatened with guns a couple times. Some people punch and wrestle each other. Someone falls from a height, but isn't hurt. A young girl is threatened with kidnapping and possible harm.
Spiritual:
God and Carthage's faith in God are mentioned a few times. The origin story for the world in which the story is set is briefly addressed and it resembles the creation story for our world.
There's mention that a lot of people in that world have beliefs that resemble astrology, thinking the stars somehow govern their fates.
July 31, 2018
The Electrical Menagerie by Mollie E. Reeder is the first book in a new Steampunk Fantasy series.
It recounts the struggles of Carthage and Huxley, two entertainers on their last dime and failing to pull in the crowds. Until the Celestial Palace announces auditions are being held to search for an act suitable and fantastic enough for the Princess's upcoming birthday. These two grab on to what seems like their last hope and bet everything on winning.
I loved this book I was instantly drawn in by the characters, they are so likable and engaging. Watching Carthage and Huxley interact with each other is hilarious; their personalities are both contrary and, strangely, compatible. The robotic butler however, steals the show with his comedic timing.
The World of the celestial isles is unique, but not as hard to grasp as one might think. Surprisingly there is very little world-building dumped on the reader. It all flows smoothly with the story action. You will never notice that there is anything unlike the familiar world nor will you feel like you received a crash course in geo-metric-physics. (yes I know that is not a thing.)
For those who keep track of these things may look at my dates read and wonder why it took me so long to finish this book. I had many reasons, first I read faster in paper than ebook, (Weird I know) I was reading multiple books at once (bad Cathrine) and the last reason is because I had a long stretch where I could do no reading whatsoever. (Not possible right?) All that to say, this is an amazing book and it took shear will power not to stay up all night and read it in one sitting. The things must get done after all.
While on my reading break, I had the rare opportunity to meet Mollie E. Reeder, and I bought her last paperback off her. The Electrical Menagerie has the unique distinction of being the only book I have started in electronic format and finished in Paperback.
It recounts the struggles of Carthage and Huxley, two entertainers on their last dime and failing to pull in the crowds. Until the Celestial Palace announces auditions are being held to search for an act suitable and fantastic enough for the Princess's upcoming birthday. These two grab on to what seems like their last hope and bet everything on winning.
I loved this book I was instantly drawn in by the characters, they are so likable and engaging. Watching Carthage and Huxley interact with each other is hilarious; their personalities are both contrary and, strangely, compatible. The robotic butler however, steals the show with his comedic timing.
The World of the celestial isles is unique, but not as hard to grasp as one might think. Surprisingly there is very little world-building dumped on the reader. It all flows smoothly with the story action. You will never notice that there is anything unlike the familiar world nor will you feel like you received a crash course in geo-metric-physics. (yes I know that is not a thing.)
For those who keep track of these things may look at my dates read and wonder why it took me so long to finish this book. I had many reasons, first I read faster in paper than ebook, (Weird I know) I was reading multiple books at once (bad Cathrine) and the last reason is because I had a long stretch where I could do no reading whatsoever. (Not possible right?) All that to say, this is an amazing book and it took shear will power not to stay up all night and read it in one sitting. The things must get done after all.
While on my reading break, I had the rare opportunity to meet Mollie E. Reeder, and I bought her last paperback off her. The Electrical Menagerie has the unique distinction of being the only book I have started in electronic format and finished in Paperback.
June 28, 2018
The Electrical Menagerie is perplexingly difficult to describe. It mixes fantasy and science fiction with heavy early-1900s, steampunk vibes and a good dash of wonder. The story takes place in a world unlike any I’ve ever encountered, either on the page or on screen: A “world” made of landmasses floating in the sky, circled by stars. I loved the subtle ways this impacted the characters’ ways of thinking, such as referring to the sun as the “Principle Star.”
In this world, electricity and mechanics take on an almost-magical quality; robots have personalities and can do fascinating things. This, combined with the two protagonists, breathed wonder across the page.
The protagonists are refreshing and lovable: Sylvester Carthage, a middle-aged man with a childlike perspective and remarkable talent for invention, and Arbrook Huxley, a clever, world-wise twenty-something with something to prove to his family and himself. Their partnership-turned-friendship was the heart and soul of this book. I’m confident that I will read any further works in this series simply because of the amazing character dynamics. On top of that, both Carthage and Huxley grew in believable, character-consistent ways throughout the story and were the driving forces in the plot.
It’s rare to find a book that appeals to both my inner child, searching for imagination and creativity and literary friends, and my inner author, searching for well-written stories with dynamic characters and compelling plots. The Electrical Menagerie did both masterfully, and is now near the top of my personal “Recommend to All the People” book list.
This book is simply magical.
In this world, electricity and mechanics take on an almost-magical quality; robots have personalities and can do fascinating things. This, combined with the two protagonists, breathed wonder across the page.
The protagonists are refreshing and lovable: Sylvester Carthage, a middle-aged man with a childlike perspective and remarkable talent for invention, and Arbrook Huxley, a clever, world-wise twenty-something with something to prove to his family and himself. Their partnership-turned-friendship was the heart and soul of this book. I’m confident that I will read any further works in this series simply because of the amazing character dynamics. On top of that, both Carthage and Huxley grew in believable, character-consistent ways throughout the story and were the driving forces in the plot.
It’s rare to find a book that appeals to both my inner child, searching for imagination and creativity and literary friends, and my inner author, searching for well-written stories with dynamic characters and compelling plots. The Electrical Menagerie did both masterfully, and is now near the top of my personal “Recommend to All the People” book list.
This book is simply magical.
December 15, 2021
This was a delightful novel with a plot that felt very different from what I'd expect in a traditional fantasy story--and in a very good way! It was a fresh, original experience and I loved the flavor of the world and characters. Would 100% read more books set in this world by this author!
Rating: 4.0 Stars (Very Good).
Rating: 4.0 Stars (Very Good).
Displaying 1 - 30 of 127 reviews