What do you think?
Rate this book
Beneath the Surface
We saw something we shouldn’t have.
Did something we shouldn’t have.
And Cruz Martinez, the bad boy of Blackwell Lake, was there to witness it all.
Now, someone is after us. Someone who knows our secret.
We need to find out what’s beneath the surface…before it’s too late.
1…2…3…4…
Whose body is lying on the lake floor?
*****
Beneath the Surface is a why-choose MMMF college suspense romance from Becca Steele and C. Lymari. This book cannot be read as a standalone.
Did something we shouldn’t have.
And Cruz Martinez, the bad boy of Blackwell Lake, was there to witness it all.
Now, someone is after us. Someone who knows our secret.
We need to find out what’s beneath the surface…before it’s too late.
1…2…3…4…
Whose body is lying on the lake floor?
*****
Beneath the Surface is a why-choose MMMF college suspense romance from Becca Steele and C. Lymari. This book cannot be read as a standalone.
Kindle Edition
Published September 27, 2024
101 people are currently reading
408 people want to read
About the author
Becca Steele
52 books4,150 followersBecca Steele is a USA Today and Wall Street Journal bestselling author of new adult romance, from contemporary to dark. Her books have been translated into multiple languages.
Becca resides in the south of England with her family. When she's not writing, you can find her reading, gaming, or curating yet another Spotify playlist.
Stalker links
http://linktr.ee/authorbeccasteele
Becca resides in the south of England with her family. When she's not writing, you can find her reading, gaming, or curating yet another Spotify playlist.
Stalker links
http://linktr.ee/authorbeccasteele
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 84 reviews
September 29, 2024
📚'B𝐄N𝐄A𝐓H T𝐇E S𝐔R𝐅A𝐂E' 📚 Is the first full length college romance book in the series 'Blackwell Lake' by author Becca Steele. The characters: Micha & Ava, Grayson & CruzWhat to expect:
🖤 MMMF Why Choose
🖤 College Romance
🖤 Suspense
🖤 Sports (Hockey)
🖤 Enemies to lovers
🖤 Friends to lovers
🖤 Bi-awakening
🖤 First in trilogy
What exactly happened that summer out on the lake at their annual end of semester party? The boat they were cruising around on hit something. Did they run over a log? Or was it a person?
Whatever it was they just all want to move on with their lives as though nothing happened that night..
Micha & Ava are besties, Grayson is the king on campus & Cruz ruled the streets. Now these four characters are thrust into a web of sticking together and finding out who is traumatising them via sinister texts. 📚....‘𝟷…𝟸…𝟹…𝟺 𝙳𝚘 𝚢𝚘𝚞 𝚔𝚗𝚘𝚠 𝚠𝚑𝚘𝚜𝚎 𝚋𝚘𝚍𝚢 𝚒𝚜 𝚍𝚎𝚌𝚊𝚢𝚒𝚗𝚐 𝚘𝚗 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚕𝚊𝚔𝚎 𝚏𝚕𝚘𝚘𝚛?’
Someone is watching them, someone is following them, someone is texting them, someone is coming for them..
With all this happening as they spend time together trying to keep each other safe they become entangled in confusing feelings which start to surface making them question their sexuality and the glue keeping them together was Ava, the beautiful girl they all wanted.
During the night where everyone is partying it up celebrating Halloween a murder is committed right under all their noses leaving us on one major cliffy making me anticipate where this story is going to lead us in the next book. This was a slow burn which got it's hooks into me as I tried to piece together the mystery surrounding the person targeting these four characters, we only know him as X.. I can't wait for the next book..
September 30, 2024
A hockey captain, a photographer and a figure skater get onto a boat…and someone is found dead.
This is bloody addicting. I’m not obsessed, and I can’t wait for the sequel.
This is bloody addicting. I’m not obsessed, and I can’t wait for the sequel.
September 27, 2024
Becca Steele and C Lymari are a picture perfect, 10/10, writing team. The concepts and stories that these two can conjure up are mind blowing, addicting, captivating, engaging, and enigmatic. Grab Beneath the Surface, a beverage, and your favorite reading spot and dig right in.
BTS follows the lives of Ava (a D1 figure skater), Grayson (captain of the college’s hockey team), Micah (media team for hockey team), and Cruz (bad boy extraordinaire). This unconventional foursome has been brought together through one mysterious event and things have never been the same since.
So, dear readers, what would you do if you received the text…
‘1…2…3…4 Do you know whose body is decaying on the lake floor?’
BTS follows the lives of Ava (a D1 figure skater), Grayson (captain of the college’s hockey team), Micah (media team for hockey team), and Cruz (bad boy extraordinaire). This unconventional foursome has been brought together through one mysterious event and things have never been the same since.
So, dear readers, what would you do if you received the text…
‘1…2…3…4 Do you know whose body is decaying on the lake floor?’
September 27, 2024
Micha and Ava are besties, Grayson is a common enemy although he doesn't know why and Cruz is the bad boy outcast - have the four of them witness something they shouldn't and you have Beneath The Surface. Throw in some hot s3xual tension between them all - yes them all, cue the bi-awakening and you have an addictive story. Especially when messages come through and danger surrounds them...
Really enjoyed it - can't wait for the next installment!!!!
*I voluntarily received an arc and this is my honest review.
Really enjoyed it - can't wait for the next installment!!!!
*I voluntarily received an arc and this is my honest review.
October 18, 2024
ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!
September 25, 2024
I pick up this book and I didn’t put it down until it was finished! First off because I love a great why choose, second because the characters drew me in right away. All four had a pull that had me turning page after page. The entire vibe between them, the attractions that whirled around between all of them and the story that brought them together. The mystery surrounding them is so intriguing, and I can’t wait to read what happens next. It had me on the edge of my seat and I hated it when it ended.
I have so many theories and wishes, I want to know what happens and where they’re going, book two can’t come soon enough.
I received an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
I have so many theories and wishes, I want to know what happens and where they’re going, book two can’t come soon enough.
I received an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
March 5, 2025
4.75*
This was so good! I honestly wasn’t sure if I was going to like this because I mostly read MM but the plot was just so interesting and I needed to know what was going to happen. Also I actually really liked the FMC in this. The ending of this was INSANE. Like what? And I need some more developments with Grayson and Micah. I literally can’t stop thinking about this book and I can’t wait for the next one!
This was so good! I honestly wasn’t sure if I was going to like this because I mostly read MM but the plot was just so interesting and I needed to know what was going to happen. Also I actually really liked the FMC in this. The ending of this was INSANE. Like what? And I need some more developments with Grayson and Micah. I literally can’t stop thinking about this book and I can’t wait for the next one!
September 27, 2024
ARC REVIEW
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
Beneath the Surface is the first book in the Blackwell Lake trilogy. It is safe to say that this book had me hooked 🎣
It’s the annual end of the semester party at the lake when Ava agrees to go on a boat ride with Grayson, the popular hockey captain of their college team, and Micah, her friend who is also the hockey teams photographer. The night out doesn’t end the way she had planned it to, and now all she wants is to forget that night and move on with her life. But it’s not long before she learns that someone knows their secret, who is determine to make sure that nothing stays buried.
This book was freaking amazing & so up my alley. It had mystery, tension, chemistry and I adored all 4 main characters. The MMC:s are very different personalities which makes you create a soft spot for each one. I can’t wait for the next book in this series & see how it all turns out.
Thank you Becca Steele, C. Lymari and Wordsmith Publicity for the opportunity to read this book before its release.
You’ll love this book if you like:
🖤 MMMF
🖤 Dark college romance
🖤 Hockey
🖤 Enemies to Lovers
🖤 Mystery a la “I know what you did last summer”
🖤 Bi-awakening
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
Beneath the Surface is the first book in the Blackwell Lake trilogy. It is safe to say that this book had me hooked 🎣
It’s the annual end of the semester party at the lake when Ava agrees to go on a boat ride with Grayson, the popular hockey captain of their college team, and Micah, her friend who is also the hockey teams photographer. The night out doesn’t end the way she had planned it to, and now all she wants is to forget that night and move on with her life. But it’s not long before she learns that someone knows their secret, who is determine to make sure that nothing stays buried.
This book was freaking amazing & so up my alley. It had mystery, tension, chemistry and I adored all 4 main characters. The MMC:s are very different personalities which makes you create a soft spot for each one. I can’t wait for the next book in this series & see how it all turns out.
Thank you Becca Steele, C. Lymari and Wordsmith Publicity for the opportunity to read this book before its release.
You’ll love this book if you like:
🖤 MMMF
🖤 Dark college romance
🖤 Hockey
🖤 Enemies to Lovers
🖤 Mystery a la “I know what you did last summer”
🖤 Bi-awakening
September 28, 2024
Seppy's 5+ Star Review:
Ava, the figure skater; Grayson, the captain of their college hockey team; Michah, the hockey team photographer; and Cruz, the bad boy, all see something they shouldn't at the end-of-semester party at the lake. They are all bothered by what they saw, but it isn't until they all get text messages from an unknown person that they four come together. They are in danger and must figure out who knows and stops them. As these four come together, feelings and emotions are explored.
OMG, that cliffhanger has me screaming, "NO"! I absolutely loved everything about this book. I was hooked and read this one cover to cover. I love Becca Steele's books, and this one doesn't disappoint. I can see there are more twists and turns for book 2, and I am ready! I love all the characters and love a why choose book that is a bit dark and full of twists and turns. I can't wait for whatever is to come next and see the characters grow and learn more about themselves, and they stick together to keep Ava and themselves safe from whoever this is. Amazing book one, One Click Today!
Ava, the figure skater; Grayson, the captain of their college hockey team; Michah, the hockey team photographer; and Cruz, the bad boy, all see something they shouldn't at the end-of-semester party at the lake. They are all bothered by what they saw, but it isn't until they all get text messages from an unknown person that they four come together. They are in danger and must figure out who knows and stops them. As these four come together, feelings and emotions are explored.
OMG, that cliffhanger has me screaming, "NO"! I absolutely loved everything about this book. I was hooked and read this one cover to cover. I love Becca Steele's books, and this one doesn't disappoint. I can see there are more twists and turns for book 2, and I am ready! I love all the characters and love a why choose book that is a bit dark and full of twists and turns. I can't wait for whatever is to come next and see the characters grow and learn more about themselves, and they stick together to keep Ava and themselves safe from whoever this is. Amazing book one, One Click Today!
October 6, 2024
1..2..3..4
Omg I need so much more! These two did a wonderful job of combining mystery with enemies turning to more! I love how we are getting mmc that have feelings and can express themselves. This is definitely more of a slow burn teasing so much more. Without giving away to much I can’t wait to see how Ava handles them all and how all 3 of the guys figure out who they are and who they want to be with!
Omg I need so much more! These two did a wonderful job of combining mystery with enemies turning to more! I love how we are getting mmc that have feelings and can express themselves. This is definitely more of a slow burn teasing so much more. Without giving away to much I can’t wait to see how Ava handles them all and how all 3 of the guys figure out who they are and who they want to be with!
October 8, 2024
This book was so freaking good from start to finish I couldn't stop reading it I kept wanting more. I'm not giving anything away, what would be the fun in that, you just have to get it and go in blind it's one wild af rollercoaster that's for sure. It gives off that I know what you did last summer vibes oh so well iykyk🤫
November 17, 2024
***4,25 "1...2...3...4..." stars***
1… 2… 3… 4 Do you know whose body is decaying on the lake floor?
Becca and Claudia when they are joining forces are pure fire and I believe that the Blackwell Lake is even more yummy that the Boneyard Kings trilogy if that is possible!
I liked everything about this book!
I liked the atmosphere, i liked our four main characters, I liked the plotline and the mystery that was surrounding this story!
And these darn messages were giving me anxiety! Who is after them and what will happen next after this explosive cliffy?
1… 2… 3… 4 I know something you don’t know.
Ava and Micah were best friends... Grayson Cross was a common enemy for both of them for their own reasons... that night these three were on the boat together and everything changed for them from that moment...
Almost a year later, they are starting to get ominous texts about that night....
Someone is after them and the only person who can be behind these texts is Cruz Ramirez, the bad boy of Blackwell. Or not?
1… 2… 3… 4 How long until bones dissolve?
These four are getting entangled in a web of secrets, lies, death and unknown feelings...
And as the time is running out for them, they are desperately trying to find out more about what loes beneath the surface..
At the same time, they are trying to stay together in an attempt for safety, but things are becoming complicated for all of them...
1… 2… 3… 4 How long until the cops are knocking on your door?
I really loved all of our three heroes and our heroine...
I loved the dynamic between them...
I didn't like what they were going through but I was on the edge of my seat for most of the time...
I loved the slow burn romance between all four of them... I just want more!
And I really need to understand more about this X and what are his motives for all this madness!
1… 2… 3… 4 You are guilty, and I know.
**I received an ARC for the exchange of an honest review**
1… 2… 3… 4 Do you know whose body is decaying on the lake floor?
Becca and Claudia when they are joining forces are pure fire and I believe that the Blackwell Lake is even more yummy that the Boneyard Kings trilogy if that is possible!
I liked everything about this book!
I liked the atmosphere, i liked our four main characters, I liked the plotline and the mystery that was surrounding this story!
And these darn messages were giving me anxiety! Who is after them and what will happen next after this explosive cliffy?
1… 2… 3… 4 I know something you don’t know.
Ava and Micah were best friends... Grayson Cross was a common enemy for both of them for their own reasons... that night these three were on the boat together and everything changed for them from that moment...
Almost a year later, they are starting to get ominous texts about that night....
Someone is after them and the only person who can be behind these texts is Cruz Ramirez, the bad boy of Blackwell. Or not?
1… 2… 3… 4 How long until bones dissolve?
These four are getting entangled in a web of secrets, lies, death and unknown feelings...
And as the time is running out for them, they are desperately trying to find out more about what loes beneath the surface..
At the same time, they are trying to stay together in an attempt for safety, but things are becoming complicated for all of them...
1… 2… 3… 4 How long until the cops are knocking on your door?
I really loved all of our three heroes and our heroine...
I loved the dynamic between them...
I didn't like what they were going through but I was on the edge of my seat for most of the time...
I loved the slow burn romance between all four of them... I just want more!
And I really need to understand more about this X and what are his motives for all this madness!
1… 2… 3… 4 You are guilty, and I know.
**I received an ARC for the exchange of an honest review**
October 24, 2024
Cruz is the only likeable character. Hope the rest die. Dnf 40%
Anybody who’s ever dealt with racism knows what subtle racism is. And 3/4 of the characters are racist towards the Hispanic character. I’m sure there’s character development later on in the book but I don’t care how much you change if you were racist towards me I’ll never date you 🤣 I’ll never sink that low.
There’s no blatant racism on page. Like slurs or anything. But subtle racism. I’ll give some examples.
The 3 white characters don’t like each other. But the immediately find comfort in each other when they start getting threatening messages. They instantly attack and accuse the only Mexican character of being the one harassing them.
Not to mention the only Mexican character is a drug dealer 🤣 could we get anymore stereotypical?
When they are at the hockey place after being chased by cops all the white characters would smile at Ava and Micah but would look at Cruz in disgust. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out why.
He’s left out and treated like a villain. Even when he tries explaining his side. They invalidate his feelings. And then they do this one thing that coddled white people do a lot which absolutely annoys me. They refuse to accept reality. Here’s the quote from Ava.
“Did he have to be so candid? Couldn’t he have let us bask in a fake security blanket for a little longer.” Then she goes on to talk about her self…
Overall all the characters are boring and typical. We have the typical boring blonde that’s different than all the other girls. Then we have the popular hockey player who’s hot as sin. Then we have the crybaby who can’t make daddy happy. And then we have the bad influence.
Anyways it’s boring and the characters are whiny. If I have to hear a spoiled white girl say life is so unfair one more time I might just pull my hair out.
(Ofc anybody can have hardships. But she has a good life and she shouldn’t take it for granted. It’s irritating listening to people with everything whine about bs)
Anyways that’s all bye ✌🏽
Anybody who’s ever dealt with racism knows what subtle racism is. And 3/4 of the characters are racist towards the Hispanic character. I’m sure there’s character development later on in the book but I don’t care how much you change if you were racist towards me I’ll never date you 🤣 I’ll never sink that low.
There’s no blatant racism on page. Like slurs or anything. But subtle racism. I’ll give some examples.
The 3 white characters don’t like each other. But the immediately find comfort in each other when they start getting threatening messages. They instantly attack and accuse the only Mexican character of being the one harassing them.
Not to mention the only Mexican character is a drug dealer 🤣 could we get anymore stereotypical?
When they are at the hockey place after being chased by cops all the white characters would smile at Ava and Micah but would look at Cruz in disgust. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out why.
He’s left out and treated like a villain. Even when he tries explaining his side. They invalidate his feelings. And then they do this one thing that coddled white people do a lot which absolutely annoys me. They refuse to accept reality. Here’s the quote from Ava.
“Did he have to be so candid? Couldn’t he have let us bask in a fake security blanket for a little longer.” Then she goes on to talk about her self…
Overall all the characters are boring and typical. We have the typical boring blonde that’s different than all the other girls. Then we have the popular hockey player who’s hot as sin. Then we have the crybaby who can’t make daddy happy. And then we have the bad influence.
Anyways it’s boring and the characters are whiny. If I have to hear a spoiled white girl say life is so unfair one more time I might just pull my hair out.
(Ofc anybody can have hardships. But she has a good life and she shouldn’t take it for granted. It’s irritating listening to people with everything whine about bs)
Anyways that’s all bye ✌🏽
October 18, 2024
Co-authors Becca Steele and C. Lymari are back with their newest series, kicking off
Blackwell Lake
Trilogy with its first book
Beneath The Surface.
This Friends to Lovers and Enemies to Lovers, Found Family, Romantic Suspense, College Sports through multiple POVs has us following the story of King of Campus/Hockey Captain of Blackwell Lake Barracudas Hockey team Grayson ‘Gray’ Cross, Photographer/Hockey Coach’s son Micah Pierce, Ice Skater Ava Hayes and Bad Boy Cruz Martinez.
This story was giving very much 90s horror I Know What You Did Last Summer meets Pretty Little Liars vibes throughout.
Then again with the journey book one alone led you on, it was to be expected. Simultaneously the story played out before your very own eyes like a movie with seeing all that took place throughout coming alive from the pages, especially with all the details that added depth.
All the whilst feeling like you were in a maze with no end in sight given the never ending mystery from the growing questions coming out of the woodworks. But no answers in sight to fill in the blanks.
From seeing and learning how an event changed Ava, Micah, Grayson and Cruz's life unknowingly, only to now connect them to one another unexpectedly.
Or seeing relationships develop and slowly yet surely flourish between each of them, given the emotions explored and evolving over time.
There was definitely a lot to see and traverse through, despite it being only book one.
Beneath The Surface was most definitely a thrilling read.
Not just from the action and thrills caused within the mystery development.
But also with how it paved the way for good character developments, connecting well to showcasing the dynamics between each of them. Particularly when it came to presenting the developing relationships it led to between Ava, Micah, Grayson and Cruz.
Not only was it intriguing to see their individual actions, but also the reactions considering the new territory being explored with the growth of unexpected dynamics to say the least.
And although the high suspense levels made it feel serious, there were some lighter moments to be had that made it entertaining too.
Considering the many tropes included within this book alone, co-authors Becca and Claudia managed to create a clear path for each.
Even with some leading to interconnections between them, it never took away for the individual shining moment being showcased loud and clear. Playing into the storyline very well as it progressed over time.
Then again with a building storyline that included mystery, suspense, horror, alongside major romantic suspense too. Courtesy of the connections from chemistry building within the dynamics forming between all the characters, ultimately paving the way for sparks to fly.
Was it any wonder co-authors Becca and Claudia had you delving in further and deeper and the story developed onwards.
Beneath The Surface definitely caught me off guard when it came to the ending, considering how co-authors Becca Steele and C. Lymari left us hanging by a thread with the cliffhanger that was delivered.
Safe to say the next book in Blackwell Lake trilogy could not come fast enough with needing answers ASAP.
*I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This Friends to Lovers and Enemies to Lovers, Found Family, Romantic Suspense, College Sports through multiple POVs has us following the story of King of Campus/Hockey Captain of Blackwell Lake Barracudas Hockey team Grayson ‘Gray’ Cross, Photographer/Hockey Coach’s son Micah Pierce, Ice Skater Ava Hayes and Bad Boy Cruz Martinez.
This story was giving very much 90s horror I Know What You Did Last Summer meets Pretty Little Liars vibes throughout.
Then again with the journey book one alone led you on, it was to be expected. Simultaneously the story played out before your very own eyes like a movie with seeing all that took place throughout coming alive from the pages, especially with all the details that added depth.
All the whilst feeling like you were in a maze with no end in sight given the never ending mystery from the growing questions coming out of the woodworks. But no answers in sight to fill in the blanks.
From seeing and learning how an event changed Ava, Micah, Grayson and Cruz's life unknowingly, only to now connect them to one another unexpectedly.
Or seeing relationships develop and slowly yet surely flourish between each of them, given the emotions explored and evolving over time.
There was definitely a lot to see and traverse through, despite it being only book one.
Beneath The Surface was most definitely a thrilling read.
Not just from the action and thrills caused within the mystery development.
But also with how it paved the way for good character developments, connecting well to showcasing the dynamics between each of them. Particularly when it came to presenting the developing relationships it led to between Ava, Micah, Grayson and Cruz.
Not only was it intriguing to see their individual actions, but also the reactions considering the new territory being explored with the growth of unexpected dynamics to say the least.
And although the high suspense levels made it feel serious, there were some lighter moments to be had that made it entertaining too.
Considering the many tropes included within this book alone, co-authors Becca and Claudia managed to create a clear path for each.
Even with some leading to interconnections between them, it never took away for the individual shining moment being showcased loud and clear. Playing into the storyline very well as it progressed over time.
Then again with a building storyline that included mystery, suspense, horror, alongside major romantic suspense too. Courtesy of the connections from chemistry building within the dynamics forming between all the characters, ultimately paving the way for sparks to fly.
Was it any wonder co-authors Becca and Claudia had you delving in further and deeper and the story developed onwards.
Beneath The Surface definitely caught me off guard when it came to the ending, considering how co-authors Becca Steele and C. Lymari left us hanging by a thread with the cliffhanger that was delivered.
Safe to say the next book in Blackwell Lake trilogy could not come fast enough with needing answers ASAP.
*I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
October 18, 2024
𝔅𝔢𝔫𝔢𝔞𝔱𝔥 𝔗𝔥𝔢 𝔖𝔲𝔯𝔣𝔞𝔠𝔢 - 𝔅𝔩𝔞𝔠𝔨𝔴𝔢𝔩𝔩 𝔏𝔞𝔨𝔢 𝔅𝔬𝔬𝔨 1 - ℜ𝔢𝔳𝔦𝔢𝔴
Authors: Becca Steele & C.Lymari
Couple: Ava with Grayson, Micah & Cruz Martinez
Tropes:
🖤 MMMF Why Choose
🖤 College Romance
🖤 Suspense
🖤 Sports (Hockey)
🖤 Enemies to lovers
🖤 Friends to lovers
🖤 Bi-awakening
🖤 First in trilogy
Review: Beneath The Surface is another 5 star stunner from Becca Steele and C. Lymari and oh what a ride they put us through with this one! This whole book was a mix of mystery, sin and depravity but only indulged us in the beginning of the suspense surrounding the accident that occurred on Blackwell Lake…or was it?? Ava was a unique FMC as an avid Becca Steele fan and I enjoyed how her story evolved as the story unfolded as well as seeing how all the men were drawn into her.
The way this author duo built up the mystery and suspense kept me hanging on by threads as we slowly learned what Ava and the guys accidentally got involved in and to saw I was shocked was an understatement. Ava, Micah, Grayson and Cruz were an unlikely group of people who I would never of matched together but also somehow fit really well with this plot and story. The way Ava was like the grounding point points to how she may have to change and push boundaries in future books but also shows that each of these men have a center of gold…in some cases hidden under a ton of ice and sharp edges.
Becca Steel and C. Lymari also took a new spin on cocky hockey alphaholes with Grayson who hands down is my favorite MMC and will stay there. The way this man’s story grew as events were unraveled captivated me. From the arrogant captain to the unsure student to the protective dude who was drawn to Ava and Micah, he absolutely destroyed what I expected for the hockey romance trope. Micah and Ava also surprised me with the way their relationship changed over time but also caused me to wish we had more now! Seeing their friendship become stronger was a highlight in this book since I have a feeling it is about to best tested as this series continues.
Beneath The Surface was not what I expected but ended up being everything I wanted in a college romantic suspense and I cannot wait for more. This book is a lot more mysterious that books I have read by these two and I am curious how the ending will go into book 2 as well as how the betrayals and secrets will push them all closer or farther away!
Rating: 100+, Beneath The Surface is an intensely mysterious romance full of intrigue, suspense and earth shattering emotions and it’s only the beginning for the Blackwell Lake series!
Thank you to Wordsmith Publicity for sending me this eARC!
Authors: Becca Steele & C.Lymari
Couple: Ava with Grayson, Micah & Cruz Martinez
Tropes:
🖤 MMMF Why Choose
🖤 College Romance
🖤 Suspense
🖤 Sports (Hockey)
🖤 Enemies to lovers
🖤 Friends to lovers
🖤 Bi-awakening
🖤 First in trilogy
Review: Beneath The Surface is another 5 star stunner from Becca Steele and C. Lymari and oh what a ride they put us through with this one! This whole book was a mix of mystery, sin and depravity but only indulged us in the beginning of the suspense surrounding the accident that occurred on Blackwell Lake…or was it?? Ava was a unique FMC as an avid Becca Steele fan and I enjoyed how her story evolved as the story unfolded as well as seeing how all the men were drawn into her.
The way this author duo built up the mystery and suspense kept me hanging on by threads as we slowly learned what Ava and the guys accidentally got involved in and to saw I was shocked was an understatement. Ava, Micah, Grayson and Cruz were an unlikely group of people who I would never of matched together but also somehow fit really well with this plot and story. The way Ava was like the grounding point points to how she may have to change and push boundaries in future books but also shows that each of these men have a center of gold…in some cases hidden under a ton of ice and sharp edges.
Becca Steel and C. Lymari also took a new spin on cocky hockey alphaholes with Grayson who hands down is my favorite MMC and will stay there. The way this man’s story grew as events were unraveled captivated me. From the arrogant captain to the unsure student to the protective dude who was drawn to Ava and Micah, he absolutely destroyed what I expected for the hockey romance trope. Micah and Ava also surprised me with the way their relationship changed over time but also caused me to wish we had more now! Seeing their friendship become stronger was a highlight in this book since I have a feeling it is about to best tested as this series continues.
Beneath The Surface was not what I expected but ended up being everything I wanted in a college romantic suspense and I cannot wait for more. This book is a lot more mysterious that books I have read by these two and I am curious how the ending will go into book 2 as well as how the betrayals and secrets will push them all closer or farther away!
Rating: 100+, Beneath The Surface is an intensely mysterious romance full of intrigue, suspense and earth shattering emotions and it’s only the beginning for the Blackwell Lake series!
Thank you to Wordsmith Publicity for sending me this eARC!
September 30, 2024
Beneath The Surface ( Blackwell Lake Book 1 )Hooked and devouring every single word , Speechless one second and screaming outta pure frustration the next , smiling, laughing, sobbing and rooting so freaking hard . What a Dup Becca Steele and C Lymari make and yes they literally just took me on the ride or my life and completely blew me away in all the best ways !!! I was without a doubt not prepared for Ava , Micah’s and Grayson incredible story . And it all starts with these three being witness’s to an event they were never meant to see , they start receiving anonymous text messages from a unknown number , each trying desperately to figure out who it could be ? And what does that mean for them? You know that feeling you get when you’re about to get on the craziest ride at the amusement park ? The feeling of being nervous and excited all at the same time ? The anticipation of what’s to come next ? Well that’s exactly how I felt from start to ending. I mean who doesn’t love a great slow burn , friends to lovers, enemies to lovers, college sports romance ( filled with mystery, intrigue, suspense, secrets , twists and turns, stalking and so much more . This may only be the first book in a trilogy but I can already tell it’s going to be a new obsession of mine 🖤💜🖤💜🖤
September 24, 2024
Beneath the Surface is full of intrigue and the four people caught in the middle of a mysterious nightmare become closer as they try to solve who is stalking them. I loved the beginning of this trilogy.
While Ava, Grayson, Micah, and Cruz are piecing together the mystery that happened when they were all at the lake last summer, these four college students also get wrapped up in a whirlwind of steamy emotions. It was great how each character had their own doubts, their own worries, and their own revelations within a growing poly group, one that they aren't even aware of, yet.
The mystery and intrigue has them constantly spinning so the relationship between everyone is a slow burn, but still delicious. The chemistry runs high between everyone and I do mean everyone, so I can't wait to watch them blossom as this trilogy continues.
The mysterious plot definitely kept me turning pages late into the night as the story weaved back and forth from past to present. While it was somewhat similar to I Know What You Did Last Summer, it was also extremely unique with its own story and twists. I'm on pins and needles for the next part of this story to continue.
While Ava, Grayson, Micah, and Cruz are piecing together the mystery that happened when they were all at the lake last summer, these four college students also get wrapped up in a whirlwind of steamy emotions. It was great how each character had their own doubts, their own worries, and their own revelations within a growing poly group, one that they aren't even aware of, yet.
The mystery and intrigue has them constantly spinning so the relationship between everyone is a slow burn, but still delicious. The chemistry runs high between everyone and I do mean everyone, so I can't wait to watch them blossom as this trilogy continues.
The mysterious plot definitely kept me turning pages late into the night as the story weaved back and forth from past to present. While it was somewhat similar to I Know What You Did Last Summer, it was also extremely unique with its own story and twists. I'm on pins and needles for the next part of this story to continue.
September 28, 2024
Beneath the surface arc review 🖤 by @authorbeccasteele & @c.lymari
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Spice: 🌶️
Characters: Ava, Cruz, Micah & Grayson
Tropes: why choose, hockey, suspense, mystery, found family, friends x enemies, friends x lovers, bi awakening
Review: what an amazing book, the suspense, the found family, the mystery I was so invested. Becca is not a new author to me as I have read all her MM books but first time reading one of her why choose book and C. Lymari is a new author to me and let me say THIS BOOK DID NOT DISAPPOINT…
From the start to finish with the text message, the mystery and the drama unfolding I couldn’t put the book down I wanted to know all the secrets and answers… and in between that we read a relationship grow between all the MCs whether they were enemies or friends to something more
I love all the characters so much but had a soft spot for my babies Micah and Cruz… I want to see their relationship develop into more.
THAT ENDIDNG THOOOOOOOOO…. Sorry I have to wait to February to know what happens
Such a good book and cannot wait for the next one 🥰
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Spice: 🌶️
Characters: Ava, Cruz, Micah & Grayson
Tropes: why choose, hockey, suspense, mystery, found family, friends x enemies, friends x lovers, bi awakening
Review: what an amazing book, the suspense, the found family, the mystery I was so invested. Becca is not a new author to me as I have read all her MM books but first time reading one of her why choose book and C. Lymari is a new author to me and let me say THIS BOOK DID NOT DISAPPOINT…
From the start to finish with the text message, the mystery and the drama unfolding I couldn’t put the book down I wanted to know all the secrets and answers… and in between that we read a relationship grow between all the MCs whether they were enemies or friends to something more
I love all the characters so much but had a soft spot for my babies Micah and Cruz… I want to see their relationship develop into more.
THAT ENDIDNG THOOOOOOOOO…. Sorry I have to wait to February to know what happens
Such a good book and cannot wait for the next one 🥰
September 30, 2024
This is a why choose, MMMF, College Romance, Slight Hockey element, enemies to lovers, friends to lovers vibes.
First book in the Blackwell Lake series and I devoured this book in one sitting once I started reading it I just couldn't put it down. The suspense element to this book is so dang good it will have you trying to figure out what the heck happened that summer, and what did they stumble upon. I honestly had slightly thought of I know what you did las summer while reading and I was oh gosh yes this is going to be good!
Becca Steele and C Lymari really brought it with this one!
Ava, Grayson, Micah and Cruz had me swooning honestly yeah it took that one summer to bring them together but the chemistry between all of them and then the kisses oh fan myself off! who knew a kiss could be hot!
This one is more of a slower burn but the development of the relationship these characters is so dang good!
I do have some questions, but my main one is WHY with that last chapter! I gasped and was like NO NO NO multiple times, but I'm just going to be here patiently awaiting book 2.
First book in the Blackwell Lake series and I devoured this book in one sitting once I started reading it I just couldn't put it down. The suspense element to this book is so dang good it will have you trying to figure out what the heck happened that summer, and what did they stumble upon. I honestly had slightly thought of I know what you did las summer while reading and I was oh gosh yes this is going to be good!
Becca Steele and C Lymari really brought it with this one!
Ava, Grayson, Micah and Cruz had me swooning honestly yeah it took that one summer to bring them together but the chemistry between all of them and then the kisses oh fan myself off! who knew a kiss could be hot!
This one is more of a slower burn but the development of the relationship these characters is so dang good!
I do have some questions, but my main one is WHY with that last chapter! I gasped and was like NO NO NO multiple times, but I'm just going to be here patiently awaiting book 2.
September 27, 2024
Wow, just wow. I loved the mystery thriller plot alongside the romance. This gave me RL Stine's Fear Street series vibes when reading about them encountering a dead body and then the mysterious texts that keep coming in. The slight horror/thriller aspect on top of the mystery/suspense with a slow developing romance between the four was perfect pacing and perfect amount of plot and spice.
Grayson, Cruz, Micah, and Ava got tangled in something, and we still don't know what. Multi-POV where we get chapters from all of them, and the last chapter is a mysterious X that ends on a cliffhanger.
MMMF, so Grayson and Micah has some bi-awakening moments, Cruz is bi, and they're all also attracted to Ava. I'm actually glad the three guys are attracted to each other (well, not sure about Cruz and Grayson yet but hoping the also develop something lol).
I've read all the MM by Becca Steele, and the one MM from C. Lymari, so this is a first RH I'm reading from their co-writing, and I'm so glad to have picked this up. I can't wait for the next book to see what happens, because I'm hoping that cliffhanger is a mistaken identity ahhhh I need to know!
Grayson, Cruz, Micah, and Ava got tangled in something, and we still don't know what. Multi-POV where we get chapters from all of them, and the last chapter is a mysterious X that ends on a cliffhanger.
MMMF, so Grayson and Micah has some bi-awakening moments, Cruz is bi, and they're all also attracted to Ava. I'm actually glad the three guys are attracted to each other (well, not sure about Cruz and Grayson yet but hoping the also develop something lol).
I've read all the MM by Becca Steele, and the one MM from C. Lymari, so this is a first RH I'm reading from their co-writing, and I'm so glad to have picked this up. I can't wait for the next book to see what happens, because I'm hoping that cliffhanger is a mistaken identity ahhhh I need to know!
September 28, 2024
During an end of the semester party on the lake things take an unexpected turn. Grayson - the hockey team captain, Micah - the team photographer, and Ava - the figure skater - see something so shocking it leaves them questioning what really happened. And Cruz - the campus bad boy - was there to witness it all. It's a night they'll never forget but wish they could.
Now they're back on campus but it looks like someone out there knows their secret. And that someone is messing with them with no apparent plans to stop. It leaves them wondering just how far they'll take things.
As they work together to try and figure who's behind this new threat and what exactly they saw, their whole dynamic starts to shift. There's a love/hate and push/pull feel to their evolving relationships with each other and as a whole unit. Tensions and emotions are building and so is the chemistry.
Be prepared for a cliffhanger that will leave you checking on that release date for book two. This was a fantastic way to start a new series. It was a great read and I can't wait to see what happens next.
Now they're back on campus but it looks like someone out there knows their secret. And that someone is messing with them with no apparent plans to stop. It leaves them wondering just how far they'll take things.
As they work together to try and figure who's behind this new threat and what exactly they saw, their whole dynamic starts to shift. There's a love/hate and push/pull feel to their evolving relationships with each other and as a whole unit. Tensions and emotions are building and so is the chemistry.
Be prepared for a cliffhanger that will leave you checking on that release date for book two. This was a fantastic way to start a new series. It was a great read and I can't wait to see what happens next.
September 30, 2024
This is the first book in a trilogy by 2 amazing authors that know how to hook you and keep you hooked all the way to the end, only to leave you not just on edge but also wanting more. That’s me. I want more and I can’t wait for the next book in this trilogy. The suspense of what will happen next keeps you on the edge of your seat. The building romance between Ava, Micah, Grayson and Cruz. They are all connected by something that happened at the end of last school year. The new school year has begun and now all 4 of them are receiving threatening and scary messages. They’re being watched without know and it just adds to the suspense as you try to figure out, along with the characters, what happened and what is going on. Everything they’re going through just brings them closer and I am totally here for it all. And OMG the cliffy just about had me screaming “Nooo! What!!!” Becca Steele and C. Lymari have knocked this first book out of the park, leaving you balancing on the edge as you wait for more to come.
October 5, 2024
This book had me hooked with the first chapter. What a great start. I legit read this book in one sitting, I could NOT put it down.
The twists and turns had me flipping those pages so fast.
All the main characters were great, Ava, Cruz, Grey and Micah. I loved how being from completely different worlds they all banned together and watched over one another.
Each of their family and lives were so different...
Cruz from the wrong side of the tracks trying to get clean of that life, Micah never measures up to what his dad wants of him, Ava the loner girl, and Grey the Hockey Capt used to getting what he wants and leading his team.
Such different personalities that fit perfectly together...
Don't want to give anything away...
This book has so many mysteries from the text to the stuff left in their lockers to the mysterious path and what lies ahead of that.
Having to wait for the next book in the series will be legit torture. I need answers now. Lol
Another great book by Becca Steele and C Lymari...
The twists and turns had me flipping those pages so fast.
All the main characters were great, Ava, Cruz, Grey and Micah. I loved how being from completely different worlds they all banned together and watched over one another.
Each of their family and lives were so different...
Cruz from the wrong side of the tracks trying to get clean of that life, Micah never measures up to what his dad wants of him, Ava the loner girl, and Grey the Hockey Capt used to getting what he wants and leading his team.
Such different personalities that fit perfectly together...
Don't want to give anything away...
This book has so many mysteries from the text to the stuff left in their lockers to the mysterious path and what lies ahead of that.
Having to wait for the next book in the series will be legit torture. I need answers now. Lol
Another great book by Becca Steele and C Lymari...
September 27, 2024
Beneath the surface” is the first book of a brand new series.
I am huge fans of both Becca Steele and C Lyamri. There’s just something about these two fantastic authors when they come together to do a cowrite.
“Beneath the surface” is an intriguing suspenseful masterpiece. Ava, Grayson, micha and Cruz are being stalked and getting sent anonymous text messages after they witnessed something they shouldn’t have one year earlier. Who is stalking them and why? As they try to uncover who is behind the texts, they develop a close bond where the lines begin to blare and their relationship dynamic changes.
This first book in the series kept me on my toes the entire way through. I cannot wait to continue this series I need it like I need my next breath. “Beneath the surface” does end in a cliffhanger. I’ll be just sitting here rocking in a corner till the next book lands on my kindle.
If your a fan of #whychoose romances with all the feels and nail biting suspense with a “I know what you did last summer” vibe then I highly urge you to pick up this amazing book!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
FIVE STARS 🌟 🌟🌟🌟🌟
I am huge fans of both Becca Steele and C Lyamri. There’s just something about these two fantastic authors when they come together to do a cowrite.
“Beneath the surface” is an intriguing suspenseful masterpiece. Ava, Grayson, micha and Cruz are being stalked and getting sent anonymous text messages after they witnessed something they shouldn’t have one year earlier. Who is stalking them and why? As they try to uncover who is behind the texts, they develop a close bond where the lines begin to blare and their relationship dynamic changes.
This first book in the series kept me on my toes the entire way through. I cannot wait to continue this series I need it like I need my next breath. “Beneath the surface” does end in a cliffhanger. I’ll be just sitting here rocking in a corner till the next book lands on my kindle.
If your a fan of #whychoose romances with all the feels and nail biting suspense with a “I know what you did last summer” vibe then I highly urge you to pick up this amazing book!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
FIVE STARS 🌟 🌟🌟🌟🌟
October 5, 2024
Interesting mystery
This very much gave Pretty Little Liars vibes and I was here for it. We’re thrown right into the mystery and although I would have liked to get to know the characters a bit more, this felt more story driven.
There is much more going on than the little snippets we were shown. It seemed like a simple mystery that required some snooping but nope. A few of those scenes and then that massive cliffhanger will completely change your view. Massive cliffhanger, be warned.
Then we have the blossoming romances which were very sweet despite the drama going on around them. This is where I would have liked to get to know the characters a bit more so we feel more invested in that part of the story. However, I think now that we have established some of the story and their history it will get better.
Loved/hated that cliffhanger and I am eagerly awaiting to see what really happened.
3.5/5
This very much gave Pretty Little Liars vibes and I was here for it. We’re thrown right into the mystery and although I would have liked to get to know the characters a bit more, this felt more story driven.
There is much more going on than the little snippets we were shown. It seemed like a simple mystery that required some snooping but nope. A few of those scenes and then that massive cliffhanger will completely change your view. Massive cliffhanger, be warned.
Then we have the blossoming romances which were very sweet despite the drama going on around them. This is where I would have liked to get to know the characters a bit more so we feel more invested in that part of the story. However, I think now that we have established some of the story and their history it will get better.
Loved/hated that cliffhanger and I am eagerly awaiting to see what really happened.
3.5/5
January 21, 2025
Before I get into my thoughts on the book, I'm going to theorize a little
I think "X" killed Livy. It was made known that Livy and Ava were dressed very similar. It's not mentioned that X made a mistake on whoever they killed. So, either Ava really is gone(99% chance that she's alive) or Livy was, in fact, the target. I just haven't thought much on why and how the other 3(and not 4) play into this. Unless Cruz isn't part of it.
This is probably the fastest burn I've ever read. It was like 0-100 reaaaaallllll fast.
I'm rating it a 3 because honestly the back and forth is too much. We read something, and then we have to read it again, in the same exact detail just with a different view/narration. Its monotonous.
It was a decent read but I feel like it's definitely a solid 3, if not a soft 2.75. I don't know if I'll keep updates on the 2nd book, but I'll probably read it if I come across it
I think "X" killed Livy. It was made known that Livy and Ava were dressed very similar. It's not mentioned that X made a mistake on whoever they killed. So, either Ava really is gone(99% chance that she's alive) or Livy was, in fact, the target. I just haven't thought much on why and how the other 3(and not 4) play into this. Unless Cruz isn't part of it.
This is probably the fastest burn I've ever read. It was like 0-100 reaaaaallllll fast.
I'm rating it a 3 because honestly the back and forth is too much. We read something, and then we have to read it again, in the same exact detail just with a different view/narration. Its monotonous.
It was a decent read but I feel like it's definitely a solid 3, if not a soft 2.75. I don't know if I'll keep updates on the 2nd book, but I'll probably read it if I come across it
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 25, 2024
Absolutely could not put this book down. I crawled into bed and decided I’ll read a couple chapters and then go to sleep. That’s what I tell myself all the time. My toxic problem? Believing that I’ll actually do just that. But did I do just that? Of course not. I read this thing well into the early morning. No regrets though because I didn’t have to work that following day. So I read it all, absolutely loving all the characters. The college hockey star, the somewhat shy hockey coach’s son (who also happens to be trained in several martial arts disciplines…because of course he would be) the sorority chick and add in the town bad boy. All this with a thrilling and intriguing plot. A mystery that I cannot unravel. Something happened that night at the lake. They saw something.…maybe. And someone knows they were there.
September 27, 2024
This book was perfect and just in time for Spooky season. It had the angst, sprinkled in some college drama, family drama, hockey, and, of course, the perfect amount of mystery.
This book totally gave me "I know what you did last summer" vibes (my millennial heart has been screaming with the vibes this book put down).
I couldn't pick a favorite male character, one minute, I was team Micah, then Grayson entered and stole the show, but once we met Cruz, everything stopped. But this continued throughout the whole book, I loved the dynamics each guy was developing with each other along with their individual time with Ava.
I can't wait to see where this story will lead us. I almost threw my kindle with that last chapter (iykyk)!
I will be telling everyone to pick this up because the vibes it's putting off are too good to pass up!
This book totally gave me "I know what you did last summer" vibes (my millennial heart has been screaming with the vibes this book put down).
I couldn't pick a favorite male character, one minute, I was team Micah, then Grayson entered and stole the show, but once we met Cruz, everything stopped. But this continued throughout the whole book, I loved the dynamics each guy was developing with each other along with their individual time with Ava.
I can't wait to see where this story will lead us. I almost threw my kindle with that last chapter (iykyk)!
I will be telling everyone to pick this up because the vibes it's putting off are too good to pass up!
September 28, 2024
My god! I was biting my nails during this book! I was incredibly lucky to get the opportunity to read this book early, as part of a ARC team and I’m so happy!
The chemistry between Ava, Grayson, Micah and Cruz was off the charts!
Cruz being carefree about who he is, throws the other guys off!
Ava is struggling to know where she belongs at this moment, between wanting to stand out or fit it.
Micah is sick of not being good enough and not living up to people’s expectations. He wants to be who he is but not sure how.
Grayson is living with pressure, as the captain of the Hockey team and being this happy go lucky guy! He is surrounded by people but still feels alone.
Together the four of them are dealing with a secret and a stalker.
That ending had me gasping! I need to know what happens next! I need answers!
The chemistry between Ava, Grayson, Micah and Cruz was off the charts!
Cruz being carefree about who he is, throws the other guys off!
Ava is struggling to know where she belongs at this moment, between wanting to stand out or fit it.
Micah is sick of not being good enough and not living up to people’s expectations. He wants to be who he is but not sure how.
Grayson is living with pressure, as the captain of the Hockey team and being this happy go lucky guy! He is surrounded by people but still feels alone.
Together the four of them are dealing with a secret and a stalker.
That ending had me gasping! I need to know what happens next! I need answers!
October 2, 2024
Review:
✨Beneath the Surface✨
Blackwell Lake#1
By B. Steele & C. Lymari
⭐5/5 ❤️5/5
✨ Why Choose Romance
✨ College Romance
✨ Hockey Romance
Ava
D1 Figure Skater
Grayson
Captain of the Hockey Team
Cruz
The Bad Boy
Micah
Media Team member for the Hockey team
1…2…3…4…
What could have the four in common? A fantastic story coming our way. There are many tropes that are bound to make this book entertaining, keeps you reading and wanting more. Because that cliffhanger? I cannot.
First things first. Brought together under really mysterious circumstances. Bound together by said circumstances. And let us not forget the delicious attraction that surrounds all of them. And that I mean literally. This is a slow burn, figuring out and developing multiple feelings and more. Everyone has his own issues to take care of. Emotionally and else.
When they all get messages they have more to find out. Like who is this and how to stop the danger that follows them. There is tension, mystery and a lot more that makes this one a must read.
✨Beneath the Surface✨
Blackwell Lake#1
By B. Steele & C. Lymari
⭐5/5 ❤️5/5
✨ Why Choose Romance
✨ College Romance
✨ Hockey Romance
Ava
D1 Figure Skater
Grayson
Captain of the Hockey Team
Cruz
The Bad Boy
Micah
Media Team member for the Hockey team
1…2…3…4…
What could have the four in common? A fantastic story coming our way. There are many tropes that are bound to make this book entertaining, keeps you reading and wanting more. Because that cliffhanger? I cannot.
First things first. Brought together under really mysterious circumstances. Bound together by said circumstances. And let us not forget the delicious attraction that surrounds all of them. And that I mean literally. This is a slow burn, figuring out and developing multiple feelings and more. Everyone has his own issues to take care of. Emotionally and else.
When they all get messages they have more to find out. Like who is this and how to stop the danger that follows them. There is tension, mystery and a lot more that makes this one a must read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 84 reviews